Brijesh's profile

2.3K Messages

 • 

35.2K Points

Saturday, January 28th, 2023 8:09 AM

Live Poll: Face-Off: Oscar-Nominated Director Duos

In the history of Oscars, only five director duos have been nominated for the 'Best Director' award with only Joel and Ethan Coen winning it for 'No Country for Old Men'.

Which of these movies do you think is the best?

List: https://www.imdb.com/list/ls562943483/

Poll: https://www.imdb.com/poll/KXeV2KTN3fM/

Champion

 • 

10K Messages

 • 

196.5K Points

2 years ago

Please correct:

In the history of the Oscars, ...

2.3K Messages

 • 

35.2K Points

Done, thanks!

10K Messages

 • 

163.9K Points

2 years ago

Your question is 100% accurate and perfectly worded, and the same time totally misleading. I suspect the number of films that were Oscar-nominated in director's category and actually had dual directors is much higher than the reported number over the past 95 years.

In the history of Oscars, only five director duos have been nominated for the 'Best Director' award with only Joel and Ethan Coen winning it for 'No Country for Old Men.

Fargo (1996) was jointly directed by Ethan and Joel Coen, yet only Joel's name was listed on the Oscar nomination.

The slight was a function of the AMPAS policy that nominees had to be officially credited in the film. The film's credits were a function of guild rules at the time. In this case, the DGA prevented more than one person from getting credit for directing Fargo and denied their dual credit, on the basis that not more than one person gets a director's credit on a film, unless they were established directing team. Since, the rule plays out as a catch-22 that you never become a credited team until you credited as such in the first place. Which the rule prevented from every happening in the first place (with the exception non-union and non-guild sanctioned work).

Plus, it was common with the advent of talkies when the Oscars were first starting out to have two directors, one to direct the dialogue and another to direct the action or everything else. Yet, despite this no dual director nominations were given during the first ten years of the Academy Awards.

(edited)

2.3K Messages

 • 

35.2K Points

I see the point and I have added a note.

I am keeping the intro as it is since as you said that it is right as per definition. 

10K Messages

 • 

163.9K Points

I think that is the right move. I would add the organizations, like the Directors Guild of America and the Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences that were responsible.

Note: In the past, some DGA and AMPAS rules prevented directing duos with being credited and nominated.

Obviously, I don't take issue with the wording. Only, that it makes it seem like a once in twenty year occurance and that quality directing duos are rare.

Which of these dual-directed movies Oscar-nominated for Best Director is the best one?

https://www.imdb.com/list/ls063432329/

10 Best Directing Duos And The Movies That Made Them Famous

(edited)

10K Messages

 • 

163.9K Points

2 years ago

FYI, I just noticed there at least two images each in the galleries of these films for their respective director duos. So, if you wanted to do an image poll you could. It is probably easier to leave it as is, but I wanted to point it out as an option.

10K Messages

 • 

163.9K Points

Nevermind, it is fine as is and not worth the effort and time to change it. Thanks, for incoporating my other comments into your poll suggestion.

It is nice to see these duos getting the recognition they deserve finally. Although, I can understand the reasoning of the past rule sole credit restriction was to protect directors from another stakeholder forcing a shared credit on them. It ended hurting, as much as, it helped due to its rigid enforcement.

(edited)

10K Messages

 • 

163.9K Points

2 years ago

Congratulations, @Brijesh​ ​

Poll Title: Face-Off: Oscar-Nominated Director Duos

Live Poll: https://www.imdb.com/poll/KXeV2KTN3fM/

Please change "Poll Suggestion" to "Live Poll" in the discussion thread title and change the settings so that it appears under "Praise" now, rather than "Idea."

 

FAQ: Updating Threads After Poll Goes Live

2.3K Messages

 • 

35.2K Points

Thank you!