FYC, your choice if you want to keep this a face-off. But, movies fall out the IMDb Top 250 all the time and then your poll becomes inaccurate and uncorrectable. If you change the question you can solve that future problem. Then, you just add more titles ,as he makes new movies that break into the IMDb Movie Top 250, without issues when they fall off the list.
Which of these current or former IMDb Top 250 listed movie directed by Quentin Tarantino is your favorite?
Thanks, Peter, nice catch. I agree the question calls for directed by and Robert Rodriguez directed both of those films, so both titles should be removed from the list. Tarantino has a writing credit on From Dusk till Dawn and acting credits on Planet Terror which likely where the mix-up originated on the website.
@Aris_Athanas It might be worth mentioning he shared the director's chair in Sin City and Grindhouse as a co-director, if you agree with a note in the answer title.
Just a thought, in Grindhouse Tarintino and Rodriguez equally directed about 45% of the movie each. The other directors helmed three of the five fake trailers. I would either list them all or even better, collectively refer to them as others. I think just listing Eli Roth misrepresents him by seemingly making him a equal with the main directors and ignores the contributions of the other two directors.
Please change "Poll Suggestion" to "Live Poll" in the discussion thread title and change the settings so that it appears under "Praise" now, rather than "Idea."
Maxence_G
4.5K Messages
•
71.2K Points
2 years ago
Django Unchained
0
0
TheOldJalapenoman
466 Messages
•
4.9K Points
2 years ago
I wish there were a "none of the above" option on this poll. This may be my least favorite director of all time.
0
0
urbanemovies
10K Messages
•
163.1K Points
2 years ago
FYC, your choice if you want to keep this a face-off. But, movies fall out the IMDb Top 250 all the time and then your poll becomes inaccurate and uncorrectable. If you change the question you can solve that future problem. Then, you just add more titles ,as he makes new movies that break into the IMDb Movie Top 250, without issues when they fall off the list.
Which of these current or former IMDb Top 250 listed movie directed by Quentin Tarantino is your favorite?
(edited)
9
0
urbanemovies
10K Messages
•
163.1K Points
2 years ago
Peter_pbn & @Aris_Athanas,
Thanks, Peter, nice catch. I agree the question calls for directed by and Robert Rodriguez directed both of those films, so both titles should be removed from the list. Tarantino has a writing credit on From Dusk till Dawn and acting credits on Planet Terror which likely where the mix-up originated on the website.
0
0
urbanemovies
10K Messages
•
163.1K Points
2 years ago
@Aris_Athanas It might be worth mentioning he shared the director's chair in Sin City and Grindhouse as a co-director, if you agree with a note in the answer title.
1
0
urbanemovies
10K Messages
•
163.1K Points
2 years ago
Just a thought, in Grindhouse Tarintino and Rodriguez equally directed about 45% of the movie each. The other directors helmed three of the five fake trailers. I would either list them all or even better, collectively refer to them as others. I think just listing Eli Roth misrepresents him by seemingly making him a equal with the main directors and ignores the contributions of the other two directors.
FYC,
He shared the director's chair in Sin City (Robert Rodriguez and Frank Miller) and in Grindhouse (Robert Rodriguez and others).
(edited)
2
0
dan_dassow
Champion
•
19.4K Messages
•
477.1K Points
2 years ago
Congratulations, @Aris_Athanas!
Quentin Tarantino in Top 250
Live Poll: https://www.imdb.com/poll/J008E5jwFTE/
Please change "Poll Suggestion" to "Live Poll" in the discussion thread title and change the settings so that it appears under "Praise" now, rather than "Idea."
FAQ: Updating Threads After Poll Goes Live
0
0
urbanemovies
10K Messages
•
163.1K Points
2 years ago
FYC, your poll thread title still says this is a face-off, which is not any longer.
Poll Thread: Face-Off: Quentin Tarantino in Top 250
Poll List: Quentin Tarantino in Top 250
0
0
Maxence_G
4.5K Messages
•
71.2K Points
2 years ago
That is like all his films except Jackie Brown lol!
0
0