Aris_Athanas's profile

11.2K Messages

 • 

193.9K Points

Thursday, April 16th, 2020

3

Why only 5.000 votes?

Watching Top 250 Series is unpleasant. There are many series with very few votes which nobody knows them and possess a place in top 250 series while other iconic series with thousands more votes are out. Why series needs only 5.000 votes to enter top 250? My opinion is that you could make top 250 series like top 250 movies and series must gather 25.000 votes to enter. What do you think?
Oldest First
Selected Oldest First

4.5K Messages

 • 

91.4K Points

6 years ago

1. The Top 250 series is years newer than the movie list.
2. Generally, television series get fewer votes than movies.

3. No one is forcing you to watch the entire Top 250 list.

A smaller vote floor brings a more diverse and actually interesting group of television series.

11.2K Messages

 • 

193.9K Points

The top 250 series is newer than the top 250 movies? So top 250 series needs corrections. Happy that you agree with me.

4.5K Messages

 • 

91.4K Points

No. I don't agree with you. Where did you read that I'm against newer things? I find much of sentimentality as toxic. 

Those who shake their canes and lament the loss of the good ole days? They don't have a cane to walk on. They tend to fall flat on their faces.

11.2K Messages

 • 

193.9K Points

You basically agreed with me without knowing it. You said that top 250 series is newer. Well, new things need corrections. So the list would be better if those corrections were made. It's good that you agree with me.

4.5K Messages

 • 

91.4K Points

"So the list would be better if those corrections were made. "
I know that they are newer. I don't think they need to be corrected. So... we disagree.

Champion

 • 

15.7K Messages

 • 

344.2K Points

Not only is the Top Rated TV list only a few years old, but IMDb has not consistently been counting votes for TV shows for as long as for movies.

For a long time, TV shows could not be rated until they were finished (or cancelled).

I think this disadvantages older shows compared to newer shows. But I guess the required number of votes will be increased over time.

11.2K Messages

 • 

193.9K Points

I also beleive that in time the number of votes will increase. They can make the list right.

11.2K Messages

 • 

193.9K Points

Btw 'no one is forcing you to watch the entire Top 250 list'. Is that so? First of all, only the persons who made the list can make a statement like that. You are just a user just as I am, you didn't make the list so the 'no one is forcing you to watch the entire Top 250 list' is just an immature argument. Secondly you lack of creativity. Stop using phrases I am using against you.  Make your own. 

Champion

 • 

7.8K Messages

 • 

129.4K Points

6 years ago


As long as it has enough votes to guarantee that different people has seen it and rated it high, I am ok with them being on the list, and I actually preffer a lower threshold as that way the list allows you to discover less seen but good series that otherwise would be forgotten, I'm ok with the 5,000 votes limit as it avoids the list being taken only by new popular series.

I remember when the threshold for movies was taken up, there was a big debate and dissapointment when many older classics were left out as they didn't reach the newer vote limit, and many noted that it was a shame that people using the top 250 to discover cinema would miss a big chunk of movie history in favor of popular newer movies. If the votes for movies also went down I would be happy.

4.5K Messages

 • 

71.8K Points

6 years ago

I think that Paok is right.

Even the Bottom 250 has a minimum of 10k votes.

It doesn't seem stupid to me to elevate the minimum votes for TV Series.

633 Messages

 • 

18.1K Points

6 years ago

I agree. Maybe 25k is too much for TV Series but 5k votes seems way too little.

11.2K Messages

 • 

193.9K Points

15.000 and we have an agreement

Champion

 • 

4.9K Messages

 • 

99K Points

6 years ago

5,000 votes voted by IMDb Top 1,000 voters only.

1. TV Series/TV Mini-Series, User Rating at least 8, Rating Count at least 10,000 (Sorted by IMDb Rating Descending) - https://www.imdb.com/search/title/?title_type=tv_series,tv_miniseries&user_rating=8.0,&num_votes=10000,&sort=user_rating,desc

582 titles as of today.

2. TV Series/TV Mini-Series, User Rating at least 8, Rating Count at least 15,000 (Sorted by IMDb Rating Descending) - https://www.imdb.com/search/title/?title_type=tv_series,tv_miniseries&user_rating=8.0,&num_votes=15000,&sort=user_rating,desc

470 titles as of today.

3. TV Series/TV Mini-Series, User Rating at least 8, Rating Count at least 20,000 (Sorted by IMDb Rating Descending) - https://www.imdb.com/search/title/?title_type=tv_series,tv_miniseries&user_rating=8.0,&num_votes=20000,&sort=user_rating,desc

399 titles as of today.

4. TV Series/TV Mini-Series, User Rating at least 8, Rating Count at least 25,000 (Sorted by IMDb Rating Descending) - https://www.imdb.com/search/title/?title_type=tv_series,tv_miniseries&user_rating=8.0,&num_votes=25000,&sort=user_rating,desc

342 titles as of today.

5. TV Series/TV Mini-Series, User Rating at least 8, Rating Count at least 30,000 (Sorted by IMDb Rating Descending) - https://www.imdb.com/search/title/?title_type=tv_series,tv_miniseries&user_rating=8.0,&num_votes=30000,&sort=user_rating,desc

305 titles as of today.


========================================================

TV Series/TV Mini-Series, User Rating at least 8, Rating Count at least 5,000 (Sorted by IMDb Rating Descending) - https://www.imdb.com/search/title/?title_type=tv_series,tv_miniseries&user_rating=8.0,&num_votes=5000,&sort=user_rating,desc

806 titles as of today.

Choosing 250 titles from a 'large' number (and variety) of titles makes a better, more accurate list as per IMDb standard.

=========================================================

"Koombiyo" 9.6 with 15,791 votes

> Not listed on Top 250. Why? Maybe similar case like 'The Mountain II'.

And there are many examples like "Koombiyo".

122 Messages

 • 

3.6K Points

6 years ago

Set the treshold to a higher level would be perfect for this list. it doesn't make sense having a 70s german or turkish tv series from the 70s that nobody but 5000 pepoles care about. it's not representive for a world standard. i mean some non us or non uk series are great and deserves to be there cause they're a bit more popular like dark, la casa de papel or gomorra. Settin the treshold to 15 20 or 25.000 (the best choice) would create a more accurate chart. Please do that :)

11.2K Messages

 • 

193.9K Points

Total agreed. That's what I believe too. But the answer I got was 'No one is forcing you to watch the entire Top 250 list'. It's very bad when grown up people act like 10 year olds.

122 Messages

 • 

3.6K Points

yes..and this is a bad thing because on this list you see like 70 new entries in the last year. too much turnover compared to the top 250 movie list. i mean it's easy for a youtube channel have 5.000 voters that give 91% of "10" votes like Pew News. It also makes no sense that those 70 new entries aren't from shows from the latest years but like I said they're mostly 30 or 40 years old tv shows that even if you want you can't see because they aired in an unknown part of the world a lot of time ago. Hope they change the system and if they want a help we can cooperate to make it better