rubyfruit76's profile
Champion

Champion

 • 

8.6K Messages

 • 

206.5K Points

Tuesday, February 17th, 2026

No Status

0

Suggestion: How Evil Is Too Evil for an Oscar? (Suggestions?)

Late in 2025, Variety magazine published an article arguing that Sean Penn, an early favorite for the 2026 Best Supporting Actor Oscar, would have a big obstacle to overcome: "Oscar voters love villains" but not "truly evil ones" unless they have a lot of charm, something that Penn's character in One Battle After Another (2025) was written to lack. The article exemplifies Christoph Waltz's Oscar winning Hans Landa in Inglourious Basterds (2009) as "witty and even playful." I was reminded of the creepy but charismatic Dr. Hannibal Lecter and Heath Ledger's fun version of Joker. Below are villains who were widely acclaimed by critics and loved by audiences. The Academy, however, was not completely won over. Some of these performances were nominated but none won the coveted statuette. Of these deserving actors, whose character do you think was, no matter how good the performance, perhaps "too evil" for the Oscar?  

List: https://www.imdb.com/list/ls4154290258/copy/

Poll: TBD

Sources:

Brandt, J.M. "15 Movie Villains Who Should Have Won an Oscar." Screen Rant.  November 3, 2016. Accessed February 10, 2026. 

Davis, Clayton "Why Oscar Voters Love Villains — Just Not Truly Evil Ones." Variety. December 18, 2025. Accessed February 6, 2026.

Oldest First
Selected Oldest First

691 Messages

 • 

9.2K Points

15 days ago

It's an interesting idea. In general, I think that in cinema in the realism genre, an evil person is not shown by showing the reality of the person and how he acts. Generally, films that are very affecting and generally cause anger in the audience are not shown, and I am not satisfied with this approach.

Champion

 • 

8.6K Messages

 • 

206.5K Points

@RezaKJoi​ Hi Reza, I've seen 14 of the 21 movies on the list and I think ten of those fourteen pretty explicitly show the morally reprehensible actions of the villains. Of the other four, two I don't remember well enough to comment on and two are fantastical PG-rated films so they're not meant to be realistic. I consider six of those ten movies to be some of the most disturbing films I've ever seen. David Lynch, for example, certainly doesn't spare any of the horror. I think 'Blue Velvet' is a masterpiece but I could never watch it very often. It's brutal.  

I agree that a lot of movies are intentionally easy on audiences, even when they shouldn't be, but I'm guessing that most of those are mainly ventures of commerce and I'm fortunate enough to be able to avoid many of them.   

(edited)

691 Messages

 • 

9.2K Points

@rubyfruit76​ I love Russian literature, and I believe it has a very powerful ability to convey the concept of pain—realistically, in great detail, and yet in a complete and profound way. In my view, cinema cannot truly represent pure evil and pain, because films are seen by thousands of times more people and therefore have a much stronger immediate impact.This reminded me of the book Everybody Lies. If I remember correctly—and I hope I do—there was a part in the book where a film had been released and faced strong opposition, based on the claim that it increased violence in society, but the author used data and facts to prove that this was not actually the case.

11.6K Messages

 • 

195.8K Points

12 days ago

I think that those chit-chat magazines just chatter around. No matter about what they write. ;D

Champion

 • 

8K Messages

 • 

131.7K Points

9 days ago

FYC:

Cody Jarrett from White Heat

Tony Montana from Scarface

The Wicked Witch of the West from The Wizard of Oz

Little Caesar from Little Caesar

Kevin from We Need to Talk About Kevin

(edited)

11.6K Messages

 • 

195.8K Points

8 days ago

It's a hard tie between my favs on that list. Mostly great picks!

Champion

 • 

16.1K Messages

 • 

348.2K Points

3 days ago

Convenient for the article to just not mention Anton Chigurh.

Champion

 • 

16.1K Messages

 • 

348.2K Points

3 days ago

FYC:

Kevin Spacey in Seven