Breumaster's profile

11.7K Messages

 • 

196.7K Points

Wednesday, February 25th, 2026

No Status

1

Poll Suggestion: Face-Off: True Events on Screen: Accuracy vs. Entertainment

Intro:

In the Netflix series Monster (2022), the story of Ed Gein is dramatized with some notable exaggerations. For example, at the beginning of the series it is suggested that Ed Gein killed his brother, for which there is no historical evidence. In another scene, an interrogator confronts Gein with the claim that he may have had up to 200 victims, whereas historical records confirm only two murders. Most of the objects found in his home were made from grave-robbed corpses, not his murder victims. These dramatizations serve suspense and narrative purposes common in true-crime and fact-based productions, but they deviate significantly from verified historical facts. How do you perceive the deviation between historical facts and dramatized portrayal in series and films based on real events? Please discuss it here.

Suggestions:

I've made up two lists. List1 is the List I wanted to use at first. 

I'm not really sure, if I should pick list1 or list2.

List 2 is a title poll and shows the covers fully, but in 2 cases doesn't contain the image I would have picked.

Which one is better? Image or title-list? List1 or list2?

List1: https://www.imdb.com/list/ls4158873588/

List2: https://www.imdb.com/list/ls4158985623/

Poll: TBD

Oldest First
Selected Oldest First

11.7K Messages

 • 

196.7K Points

23 days ago

P.S.: All checked for ASCII-conformity. The Intro as well as the options and the title.

1.2K Messages

 • 

13K Points

Great idea.

Younger me would have gone with option 1.Current me - option 4.

11.7K Messages

 • 

196.7K Points

@NYVKE​ 

Looks like we have some things in common. I often see that.

1.2K Messages

 • 

13K Points

@Breumaster​ 

🙂

691 Messages

 • 

9.2K Points

23 days ago

1- please remove: 

Please discuss it here.

Suggestions:

n/a

2: if you like add: https://www.imdb.com/list/ls4158873588/copy

3-  https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0416449/mediaviewer/rm4047475713/?ref_=ttmi_mi_8_1

A stylized action film that presents a heavily distorted and unrealistic image of ancient Persians. The movie replaces documented history with fantasy, turning real people and cultures into exaggerated villains for dramatic effect. Its portrayal has little connection to historical records and is widely criticized for misrepresenting Iranian civilization. The result is entertainment built on imagery that is more offensive and misleading than factual.

11.7K Messages

 • 

196.7K Points

@RezaKJoi​ 

Why should I remove it? I do it like that for eight years.

I though about putting there a copy link, but as there are just cover of titles it's not necessary.

This is a face-off  about basically real events. 300 is an adaption of a high-class comic book which I don't count as movie about real events.

300 (2006), directed by Zack Snyder, is not a historically accurate war film. It is a stylized adaptation of Frank Miller’s graphic novel, not a direct interpretation of ancient sources like Herodotus. While the Battle of Thermopylae did occur in 480 BCE and Leonidas was a real Spartan king, the film heavily exaggerates Persian numbers, distorts Persian culture, and portrays Xerxes in a mythic, almost fantasy-like way. It should be categorized as a mythologized or graphic-novel interpretation of history rather than a realistic historical drama. It's an artful adaption of a high-class comic book, which doesn't have the aspiration to tell a true story.

And another thing: Face-Offs can only contain 5 options. I have chosen my picks carefully so that Americans and the western world understand them best.

The options are ranked in terms of their accuracy according to the examples, from “too much fiction” down to “highest accuracy.” If I had placed the suggestion in third position, it would have rendered the ranking absurd.

 

(edited)

691 Messages

 • 

9.2K Points

@Breumaster​ 1- I meant the end of this text (right here), not in the main list.(You deleted these texts:

Suggestions:

 

n/a

)

 

2- Your first list is probably private; it doesn’t show up.

3- I understood your point about my suggestion; thanks for the explanation.

(edited)

11.7K Messages

 • 

196.7K Points

@RezaKJoi​ 

Thank you for pointing out. 

The link was broken and I didn't get it.

Now it works. :D