Live Poll: Superhero Anti-Heroes?

Hi Dibby, I like that. Yours has a certain ring to and I like the subtle irony it so I'll definitely consider it. I like the original title because I love repetition and I'm thinking it might be more precise. I'm not sure, though. I'll sit with both for a while to decide which one I like better and which one I think fits better. Thanks so much!

Wow, this was really helpful. I added all of them, although I chose some different photos (just for cropping reasons). Thank you so much!

I agree with Nikolay. Old Batman was more an anti hero than Dark Knight's.

Oh, I was so tired last night that I misunderstood him -- I thought that he was referring to Darkman. See? My knowledge of the genre is a pittance, lol.

You don't have to be Kevin Smith to understand this stuff, rubyfruit76. You just happened to be tired when reading Nikolay Yeriomin's remarks. What did you misunderstand, though?

In which movie or TV program does Two-Face appear? What characters in 'Kick Ass?' Thank you!

Count two face out. His personality as Harvey Dent could be an anti- hero, but not as two-face.

Jim Carrey- as Stanley Ipkiss Hit Girl in Kick Ass:/

The Mask is a smooth criminal. The reminds me... Loki...

Thank you, Mr. Tharindu! I added Hit-Girl and Stanley/The Mask but not Two-Face. I really appreciate it. :)

Jeorj, do you mean to suggest Loki as an anti-hero superhero? He's not a villian?

Hi, rubyfruit76. I'm not sure. In the MCU, he has been the villain several times, even though mischief is really is main thing.

rubyfruit76, I like the image you've chosen of hit-girl. But since it's a image list, both Mark Strong and Chloë Grace Moretz will be shown as hit girls. :)

That kind of thing often happens with image lists, which is why it's always important to put the character's name in the note field and put it in bold or another color besides black to draw attention to it. We used to be able to make "character lists" but IMDb changed some things so now all polls about characters have to be image lists and old polls that used character lists no longer appear. Many of us who had made polls based on character lists have "recasted" some of those polls as image polls. (This isn't a recast, though.)

Just pointing it out.:D By the way, don't you think there aren't enough images of Black Panther on the list. :P (Or are you trying to keep poll from going live? :/ )

Lol. I just couldn't decide which one would crop the best and also be bright enough. I also had about five different photos of Batman and Harley Quinn. :)

Thank you so much! I'll add him.

Added. :)

Thanks ;)

Well, it really depends on version. 1989's Batman, as well as one seen in the comic Dark Knight Returns is a deeply traumatized and eve somewhat unstable human being. Maybe not a textbook antihero, but quite close.

Like I said above, I know next to nothing about superheroes but Batman was mentioned in much of the research I did before starting this poll. Also, I actually did see Tim Burton's 'Batman' a few times, saw 'The Dark Knight' films, and my ex-boyfriend was a huge Dark Knight fan from the time he was a child, long before the movies came out, and I remember, from what I learned from him, thinking that both Batmans were anti-heroes because they had dark moods and worldview and, like Nikolay said, both were traumatized and somewhat unstable. I see Superman as a typical hero. Batman has a moral code but he has none of the patriotic veneer, optimistic worldview, or happy demeanor, and often relishes moments of revenge, not only justice. He's a dark character in many ways, in many of his personifications, which is the opposite of a key conventionally heroic trait.

Jeorj Euler have you seen Frank Miller's spin off kind of story "Dark Knight Returns?"Ending of it makes batman more anti-hero than a hero. Not always but sometimes batman is shown that way.

Hi, තරිඳු ධනංජය. I've not seen "Dark Knight Returns", but I've bee meaning to see it. I guess I'm used to the the Batman of the animated series, Arkham video games, Nolan movie trio, Burton movie duo, Schumacher movie duo and the campy 1960s television series. Now that I think about it, the Batman of DCEU is kind of shitty in the sense of that he brands criminals, and he actually tried to end Superman's life. I don't know what to express about the Heller show, because everybody is "crazy" in Gotham (except for Lucius Fox), and Mazouz's character is just sort of caught up in it all. It's like an eclectic, post-apocalyptic, over-the-top gift that keeps on giving.

Yes, I also like when batman is the only hero figure in a movie. I guess it was a good call when I decided not to watch ongoing TV Series. (Gotham too) :D

Gotham has something of a mixture of all the styles found in the Batman live-action movies from 1989 to 2012, but it is extremely dark, gritty and emotional, like Batman Returns, with a small about of ridiculous-yet-captivating themes. It suffers from some of the same things that lots of television series do, such as character resurrections, plot holes and loose ends; elements to compensate for the lack of a fully-formed geared-up Batman occupational presence. The word to describe its draw would be "guilty pleasure". Maybe that is part of what is preventing it from being cancelled or quick-wrapped too.

Jeorj Euler one of the best things about "Gotham" is how it manages to seamlessly combine many previously unused elements from the comics, Burton's eclectic stylistic idiosyncracy, Nolan's revisionist approach and its own brand of madness into one of the best shows on the screen right now.

Thank you for letting me know about Scarlet Witch / Black Widow. I know nothing about superheroes and have never seen any of the movies except Batman, The Dark Knight, and one or two Spidermans, which reminds me: can you let me know in what movies the characters you suggested appear? Thank you!

Red Hood https://www.imdb.com/title/tt1569923/mediaviewer/rm318275584 Spawn https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0118475/mediaviewer/rm4011864064 Blade https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0187738/mediaviewer/rm192884992 Electra https://www.imdb.com/title/tt3322312/mediaviewer/rm4186906112 Ghost Rider https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0259324/mediaviewer/rm2978060544 Jesse Custer https://www.imdb.com/title/tt5016504/mediaviewer/rm1088105472 Morbius I had to add a photo, it is processing now. Jonah Hex https://www.imdb.com/title/tt1075747/mediaviewer/rm60897792 Lobo https://www.imdb.com/title/tt1509745/mediaviewer/rm2864782848

Red hood Isn't a character based on a single person. :/ Wikipedia says, "The Red Hood is an alias used by multiple fictional characters and a criminal organization appearing in American comic books published by DC Comics." I don't know about others but red hood doesn't suit here :/

Then we will say Jason Todd. If we are going by that Batman and the Green Arrow would be out as well. Dick Grayson has been Batman and John Diggle has been Arrow.

What about Killing Joke?Joker is Red Hood in that one. :/

I said we can switch the option from Red Hood to Jason Todd to single in on one character. I have seen Killing Joke and know in that version of Joker he started in the Red Hood gang. Photo for Morbius https://www.imdb.com/title/tt1722512/mediaviewer/rm1793016832

Oh wow, thank you Ndb! I really appreciate you going to such lengths. Thank you for being so generous with your help; I'll be adding these as soon as I get some sleep, lol.

Thank you, S! I'll add her first thing tomorrow.

Because I couldn't decide which were most well-lit and cropped the best.

Hey, who the hell is Deadpoll? :P

Deadpool's evil twin brother. ; ) Thank you for pointing that out! I need to seriously proofread it after I get some sleep.

Freudian slip? :P

Hahaha, I hope not. :)

The new Venom must be Venom. (Venom) Since the upcoming movie's venom is promised to be different from the older versions you can leave it that way too, if you want to. :)

SeventhAr7 suggested "the new Venom," so that's what I wrote because I wouldn't have any idea of the difference. Are you saying that's ok or that I should just change it to "Venom" instead of "the new Venom?"

Both ways are fine, I think. :/ But, it'll be different from other characters. You don't have names like "old batman". :P

Both Jason Todd and Damien Wayne.Damien as batman is a perfect example for an Anti-hero. :)

Yeah, neither T'Challa nor Tony is particularly antiheroic. However, both were shown jumping on the Winter Soldier hate train, as far as the live-action movies go.

I don't know hardly a thing about superheroes except from research that I've done for polls. I think the only superhero movies I've seen are the Toby Maguire Spidermans, the Burton Batman, and some of one or two of Nolan's Dark Knights. I found several interviews of Chadwick Boseman in which he argues, quite persuasively, that Black Panther is an archetypal anti-hero. I was hesitant to add him because I hadn't seen the film but I've only seen one of the movies or series represented on the list (V for Vendetta) and Boseman's assertions were pretty strong. Also, I thought the list could use some racial diversity, but if you all think that he's not an anti-hero, I'll reconsider and probably remove him. LD, where are you? :)

Ahem. T'Challa can be replaced with Deadshot then. Haha.

(Although, Deadshot is one of the cases where they changed to color of the character, like what happened to Nick Fury.)

However, it’s interesting that T‘Challa is an absolute monarch who rules over an insanely rich kingdom but refuses to share any of its technology or wealth with other countries. There are hints that this policy may change in the last scene, but even villains can have an arc. An expert on the comic/movie may contradict me, but as far as I can tell, T‘Challa loses his Black Panther powers in a fair fight, then regains these powers (illegally? because only the king is supposed to possess them) and uses them to launch an attack on the current king. And all this without an explicit moral reason. T‘Challa just thinks he should be king because he‘s used to it. Killmonger is not a hero either, he‘s fine with being an absolute ruler and his thirst for blood doesn‘t help. But at least it‘s his concern to open Wakanda to the world and help those in need. So actually, T‘Challa is not even an anti-hero but a (partially redeemed) villain, and Black Panther is a fight of Bad vs. Bad. But I get carried away... we should look for who the movie thinks is the villain. Chadwick Boseman plays his character with a noble or friendly look, while Michael B. Jordan makes a more aggressive impression. ‚Evil’ music plays when Killmonger sits on the throne, and triumphant music plays when T‘Challa wins. When Killmonger murders someone, it‘s an important character and we see the death, while when T‘Challa and his gang wreak havoc in Busan we see no victims of destruction so we must assume it‘s not that bad. So okay, T‘Challa is the hero of the movie, even though a large part of the audience would oppose what he stands for.

I am trying to remember the movie, but I believe he hasn't been ruler for very long and is just getting used to having the power. He makes some bad decisions early. Overall he had hero qualities opposed to villain ones. He didn't seem like he was opposed to sharing their tech with the rest of the world; he just didn't know the best way to go about it. T'Challa would have been fine with not being king if he had lost to a respectable person. T'Challa yielded and Killmonger didn't care. Boseman argues that Black Panther is an Anti-Villain and in this movie he could be but I think overall as a character in all depictions he is a hero. That is why I said this is a little complicated as there are so many stories about each character now that their morals get adjusted.

NDbportmanfan 1 - you make good points. But at least they prove that something is rotten in the state of Wakanda if so much depends on one person, and that person's power is enhanced by super technology. T'Challa would have been fine with not being king if he had lost to a respectable person. T'Challa yielded and Killmonger didn't care. Then the system in how to choose a king is wrong, if a literal Killmonger can ascend the throne with mere physical force. But T'Challa is fine with the system as long as the results are as he likes them (which could include that he yields to a respectable person - someone respectable to him; but the law shouldn't care whether the last king finds his successor respectable).Anyway, sorry for opening this digression, I just found the topic interesting because there are many dubious points (in my opinion) about the main character. But the list is fine without him.

T'Challa is not to blame for Wakanda's political system and customs. Isolationist policies are not inherently villainous. The throne challenge system requires a fight to the death. T'Challa survived the fight.

But at least they prove that something is rotten in the state of Wakanda if so much depends on one person, and that person's power is enhanced by super technology. Yes, there is something rotten in Wakanda especially what was carried out by T'Chaka but at this those problems have been brought to light and now T'Challa will try and fix it. Also there are other tribes in Wakanda with leaders, T'Challa is just the main one. Power is somewhat balanced between the tribes.

Left- Black Panther, Right - Poll board Kick him out.. :D

We can keep T'Challa on account his initial behavior toward the Bucky in Captain America: Civil War. (Spoiler to follow?) The problem is that Tony exhibited the almost the exact same behavior. If not for that, some of us want to save T'Challa from being classified as antiheroic. He a hero, not a villain, not an antihero.

If we still had the message boards we could carry our discussion there but I‘m afraid it only causes confusion for the poll in question. So sorry again for the digression, and I want to repeat it was not my intent to question the poll, just to make a side remark.

Ruby, The IMDb has removed the image for #27The new Venom.