therichmeister's profile

71 Messages

 • 

1.8K Points

Friday, December 4th, 2020

Closed

anomalous "B positive" series rating versus episode ratings

The new series "B positive" has an unusual series rating. The series rating is (5.1) an outlier versus the 3 episodes with ratings (6.0, 7.1, 7.7). The series rating itself has an anomalous distribution (137 out of 603 votes are 1-star). IMDb has safeguards against ballot-stuffing, but these 137 1-star votes are skewing the series rating. I would like to think that I could convince 137 of my friends to do anything (if I were so inclined). :-)

Oldest First
Selected Oldest First

Champion

 • 

5.1K Messages

 • 

118.7K Points

5 years ago

https://www.imdb.com/title/tt11839500/ratings

Seeing the difference between series and episodes here really lends credence to the request (posted somewhere here on sprinklr) that a series rating should be constructed from the episode ratings.

Seeing that arithmetic mean of the 21 Top-1000 voters is 3.8 (7 gave it a 1) makes me wonder if the right voters are included in the Top-1000 (which I believe should be expanded to 10,000). Do these voters have normally-distributed ratings patterns? Or do they usually vote at the extremes? Have they voted with consistent frequency over a long period of time? Or have they voted for a _lot_ of titles in a brief period of time?

I know IMDb is not going to answer those questions. They keep their algorithms private to avoid giving the ill-intentioned the ability to circumvent them. But I wonder if they've considered the Top-1000 membership well enough. I see a _lot_ of low ratings among that group for most of the titles where I look at the ratings demographics.