Problem accessing my old account that was connected via Facebook

Good morning, 

After the removal of Facebook from my account, I tried resetting my password and it seems I have lost all of my account history. For whatever reason it looks like i have 2 accounts connected to the same email. This new sign is says I have been a member since October 2021, however it is not my userID and I have had my original account for much much longer. 

Can anyone help me get access to my original account?