122 Messages
•
3.6K Points
IMDB Top 250 with a Metacritic Filter
What about using a metacritic filter to allow movies to be in the top 250 list?
Metascore has been introduced in 1999 so i think that every movie from 2000 til now to be allowed to be on the list has to have a metascore rating
In this way you will have the real popular and more apreciated movies. In this way you can get rid of movies whose votes are clearly manipulated by their diehard fans.
This idea will delete from the list the following movies:
91. Taare Zamen Paar
107. Dangal
138. Jai Bhim
194. Mary and Max
204. Andhadhun
226. Hachi
242. Drishyam
245. Yedinci Kogustaki Mucize
246. Hera Pheri
247. Tumbbad
250. Soorarai Pottru
This Idea is great in many ways:
-You will keep the best Indian Movies on the list: Gangs of Wasseypur, Phater Panchali and 3 Idiots.
-You delete US Hallmark tv movies like Hachi
-You will keep only the best and most acclaimed foreign movies like Oldboy, Incendies, Der Untergang, El Secreto De Sus Ojos, Relatos Salvajes, Mademoiselle, Parasite, ecc.. a lot of great foreign films. The BEST
In this way you can avoid manipulated film to be on the list. Even if a movie has a rating of 9.9 by 25.000 family members that gave to that movie only 10s it can't make the list if it hasn't a metascore rating.
We can create room for 10 more movies and great quality comebacks in the list.
What you think of that?
honolulu_styles
122 Messages
•
3.6K Points
4 years ago
Those movies have the following "top1000 voters" votes:
91. Taare Zamen Paar 6,2
107. Dangal 6,5
138. Jai Bhim 4,7 (with a 9.3 rating !!!)
194. Mary and Max 7,3
204. Andhadhun 6,4
226. Hachi 7,2
242. Drishyam 5,6
245. Yedinci Kogustaki Mucize 6,3
246. Hera Pheri 4,8
247. Tumbbad 6,2
250. Soorarai Pottru 5,2
I know top 1000 voters are not the bible but you can clearly see that those are all average votes not worth to be on a list of BEST movies.
0
honolulu_styles
122 Messages
•
3.6K Points
4 years ago
babam ve oglum at 183. won't make the cut either
0
honolulu_styles
122 Messages
•
3.6K Points
4 years ago
At this link you will find what the list would look like:
https://www.imdb.com/list/ls047891203/
IN:
-Le notti di Cabiria
-Andrei Rublev
-Princess Bride
-Neon Genesis: The End of Evangelion
-Paris, Texas
-Trois Colours: Rouge
-Tangerines
-The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance
-Rififi
-Sunrise
-Throne of Blood
-Soul
A lot of more quality list would be
0
0
BonaFideBOSS
6.8K Messages
•
128.4K Points
4 years ago
According to your "idea", these movies will not make it to IMDb Top 250 either.
... and many more.
Btw, 25 movies from the list you posted above does not have a Metacritic rating.
Check out: IMDb Top 250 Movies With No Metascore
You can use the Advanced Search feature to see movies that are on both IMDb Top 250 and Metacritic.
1
0
honolulu_styles
122 Messages
•
3.6K Points
4 years ago
0
0