Employee
•
59 Messages
•
2.5K Points
Updates to Characters
Today we are modifying the display of Characters across IMDb. After in-depth discussion and examination, we have decided to simplify the display of Characters on IMDb, focusing our on-going efforts towards title specific character details. While in concept, we love the idea of character data spanning across all titles, in practice we do not feel our past experience lived up to expectations. The majority of our previous character pages were dead ends, without any related content, providing a confusing and disjointed experience. The filmography credits were often unusable, and the bios many times were inconsistent given numerous disparate story lines. While the previous experience had drawbacks, we truly appreciate all the hard work of everyonewho contributed to characters over the years. That said, as of today, we are simplifying the experience, allowing us to retain the character concept while building a foundation for future growth.With today’s release we have begun this transition. Our new character experience will support title specific images, quotes, and keywords. Moving forward we will no longer support character filmography, biographies, videos, character lists or polls. To aid in this transition, we are temporarily retaining our prior character experience until Dec 6th. This will provide our users time to archive any character lists, polls or biographies which they previously created or contributed towards. If you wish to migrate any character lists or polls, we recommend rebuilding the content with an image list. Existing character lists can also be archived by selecting the “Export this list” option. During this transition, we have temporarily retained the character search option, but will suspend support after Dec 6th. In the coming months, we plan to re-enable character search based on our new experience. We understand this is a significant change which was made only after careful consideration. We appreciate your understanding.Here is an example of the new experiencehttp://www.imdb.com/title/tt0080684/characters/nm0000148Nic
ACT_1
8.7K Messages
•
177.7K Points
7 years ago
Changes to IMDb CharactersToday we are modifying the display of Characters across IMDb.... by Nic Bachhuber, Official Rep Joined on October 17, 2014 https://getsatisfaction.com/people/nic_bachhuber_6867878https://getsatisfaction.com/imdb/people/nic_bachhuber_6867878- - - You should add Today's date : November 14 2017 Any changes to the fact (?) that WE can not search and find a Character that does not have a Character page
27
gromit82
Champion
•
7.6K Messages
•
277.8K Points
7 years ago
Our new character experience will support title specific images, quotes, and keywords. Nic: I see how images and quotes factor into this, but I don't understand what keywords have to do with title/character pages. In the coming months, we plan to re-enable character search based on our new experience.So, after December 6, if someone is wondering, "What was the movie where there was a character named Ugarte?", will they be able to find it?If I understand correctly, there will be a page at http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0034583/characters/nm0000048 showing pictures of Peter Lorre as Ugarte in Casablanca and a bunch of quotes from the character. Right? But will there be any way to search for that character and find that page, if one doesn't know the film title or the performer's name?
16
kyle_perez_8yd0eqcwxu1mz
2K Messages
•
47K Points
7 years ago
Hi Nic,What do you mean by "Archiving a poll"? Our polls have ongoing vote totals attached to them, so will this function be able to transfer over from a character poll to an image poll?Thanks and let me know when you can.
3
jeorj_euler
10.7K Messages
•
225.6K Points
7 years ago
Thanks for the advanced notice.
0
0
dan_dassow
Champion
•
19.7K Messages
•
480.1K Points
7 years ago
1. As part of this change, IMDb will no long be supporting character lists and polls after Dec 6, 2017. If you wish to retain your past Character polls, they recommend recreating any Character Lists as an Image List and then building the poll using the new image list. They apologize for any inconvenience this has caused, and want to stress the decision to deprecate their existing Character experience has been an extremely difficult one.2. To aid your effort in identifying your character polls, I’ve created this list of 843 character polls as of 8-Nov-2017. The polls are sorted in descending order of votes on the first tab and by author on the second tab.https://drive.google.com/file/d/1PJNRJC2Ld-0_yzPjCExQr0Q7R_-ApAGP/view?usp=sharingorhttps://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1LV_vFEXD9tg90B-Ko5pPJbtVUgjwizrPGZf1MS0Udtw/edit?usp=sharing3. If I have your email address, I will also send this message to you via email along with a copy of the Excel spreadsheet.4. I recommend recreating your live character polls and pending polls as soon as practical. IMDb is unlikely to extend their deadline and will probably make the change at midnight GMT (London Standard Time).5. IMDb will be adding additional wording on the site. For example, we’ll include a large message on the character pages themselves, referencing the Get Satisfaction message.6. The images (which are associated to a specific title/name will still be visible on the new character pages). In general, if you add a still_frame to a title and tag it to a name, it will automatically appear on the new character page. The same is true for a quote. If a quote is added to a name for a specific title, it will automatically appear on the new character page. A new character page will “exist” if it has at least 1 quote/image7. Recasting a poll from a character based poll to an image based poll will effectively create a new poll with no voting history.8. At this time, IMDb is unable to transfer poll counts to the new poll.9. It’s not realistic to recreate all existing polls; I recommend reviewing the top character polls and recreating those as new polls, but not the full list. Please note, anyone who has a poll taker badge will still have the same “count” post taking down the character polls.10. When someone accesses a character based list or poll on and after December 6, 2017, the user well see a 404 (page not found) error.11. I am attempting to archive as many of the character polls as possible on the Internet Archive (https://archive.org/). I am archiving the polls with the most votes first. Many of the lists, polls and poll results may already be archived. However, I would not count on these being archive. For instance, I’ve specifically archive this poll to the Internet Archive:Poll: Who Are You?List: https://web.archive.org/web/*/http://www.imdb.com/list/ls056811342/ Poll: https://web.archive.org/web/*/http://www.imdb.com/poll/1wyam4mgszE/ Poll Results: https://web.archive.org/web/*/http://www.imdb.com/poll/1wyam4mgszE/results12. I will create a separate thread where you can post the links to polls that you’ve converted from character polls to image polls. It’s not practical to push all of the recreated polls at once. The recreated polls still need to be reviewed to ensure they will work properly. The admin will push a certain number of recreated polls per day while still pushing new polls.Ideally, the original authors for polls will have preference over other authors. Given the short suspense time, this may not be practical.
6
tom_shortell
2 Messages
•
530 Points
7 years ago
Very disappointing.
0
dan_dassow
Champion
•
19.7K Messages
•
480.1K Points
7 years ago
Nic,An image may be accessed via two different URLs (links), one from the title page and another from the character page.For example:http://www.imdb.com/character/ch0383426/mediaviewer/rm985594112http://www.imdb.com/title/tt2179136/mediaviewer/rm3346727168Are links for the same image.If the character page URL is used instead of title page URL to make the image list, will there be any problem after Dec 6?= = =In essence, when a character appears in multiple titles, there will be a character page for each title. A character page is defined explicitly by the title ID and name ID. Is this correct? Star Wars: Episode IV - A New Hope (1977) Harrison Ford: Han Solohttp://www.imdb.com/title/tt0076759/characters/nm0000148 Star Wars: Episode V - The Empire Strikes Back (1980) Harrison Ford: Han Solohttp://www.imdb.com/title/tt0080684/characters/nm0000148 Star Wars: Episode VI - Return of the Jedi (1983) Harrison Ford: Han Solohttp://www.imdb.com/title/tt0086190/characters/nm0000148 Star Wars: The Force Awakens (2015) Harrison Ford: Han Solohttp://www.imdb.com/title/tt2488496/characters/nm0000148= = =Will this kind of link will work after December 6, 2017?[link=nm0000148]http://www.imdb.com/name/nm0000148/Harrison Ford
4
wolfie_1114787
34 Messages
•
1.1K Points
7 years ago
How do you access the new character pages, without manipulating URL's?
8
gbg56jw1yydx8
1 Message
•
262 Points
7 years ago
First watchlist, now characters pages... Very dissapointing changes indeed. Please, stop ruining IMDB
1
jen_264364
Champion
•
4.3K Messages
•
88.6K Points
7 years ago
When remaking already published polls, I was thinking of trying to put the remade poll options in the order of the votes as they are right now and put the vote counts in the description areas for each option. For example, here is one I already remade vs. the current version:Current poll as published: http://www.imdb.com/poll/C1W-zbjcRyQRemade: http://www.imdb.com/list/ls027056203Is this acceptable/advisable? Or should the list just be remade in the order/manner that it is right now and thus completely lose any evidence of previous vote totals?
6
sai_arun_muthusamy
262 Messages
•
8.2K Points
7 years ago
So far, what I'm getting from this is a filter for anyone to see a character's quotes on a specific title. Fair enough. But when I click a character page link, I expect and NEED to be taken to the main character page! There should be a link in place to be taken to the main character page, getting rid of it does no one any good.
6
khaledkalache
79 Messages
•
1.6K Points
7 years ago
What if I voted on a character poll .. the count of that vote will be removed?
4
buck_turgidson
1 Message
•
300 Points
7 years ago
It's a remarkably stupid idea to delete productive content in order to justify uniformity of ephemeral "user experience". But let's pretend this was the right way to proceed, in general. I'm less concerned about moving/recreating character polls than about other associated content, specifically, bios, cross-links and searchability. While much of IMDb use is effectively fandom or trying to recall the cast in a particular movie, character pages that had content had served effectively as research vehicles. Removing bios, cross-links and searches by character name effectively kills IMDb as a research tool (much as Google Books lost research value once Google removed chronological listings). To make matters worse, this will make series pages effectively useless. There's already a proble in trying to decipher cast & characters of any show with more than 3 episodes. Inability to search for non-lead characters makes pages for these shows completely superficial. Hopefully, search features will be restored sooner rather than later. But the proper way of handling the transition would've been to archive the content being eliminated (except polls) and offer the link to that content at the bottom of new character pages. Why this was not done is puzzling. The whole premise is that there's an insufficient number of content-specific character pages, so archiving them would not be a burden. And both archiving and linking could've been automated without much cost. Instead, we got stupid, stupid, stupid...
1
sandra_a2x5k8b0z9704
3 Messages
•
160 Points
7 years ago
While the temporary disappearence of the old character pages is sad, that new feature/improvement is very welcome!
10
0
hans_bomers
4 Messages
•
690 Points
7 years ago
Nooo..... :(I loved this function, despite it's (minor) faults.Removing it altogether means removing access to a source of information ('what titles had a Sherlock Holmes character in it, and who played them') for which it will be hard to get a good and easily accessible answer, without IMDb.I mean, even if the data wasn't 100% correct or complete all of the time, it was still the most comprehensive and most easily accessible source for this kind of information that I know of. Besides: even if there are other websites where I can find an answer; I don't really want to have to do that, because I go to IMDb for my film/series information. For a number of reasons. :/I also feel like you could have taken other steps than deciding to remove the function altogether. You could have made it more accessible to 'crowd-sourcing' the addition and correcting of incomplete/incorrect data on the character pages. I have found myself correcting the occasional entry now and then, and I found the process a little tedious. Nevertheless, like I said the function certainly has/had it's merit.Also, after deleting the Message boards, I hope this trend of removing functionality from the IMDb website isn't going to continue much further. :(
5