Sir_Launcelot's profile

34 Messages

 • 

1K Points

Sunday, November 22nd, 2026

Acknowledged

CATASTROPHIC KEYWORD DELETION!!!

I just discovered the keyword "u.s.-marine", you know the men who have been laying down their lives in every major war for the U.S. since 1775, has been deleted. Congratulations. There were 1000s of entries for this keyword. This is terrible. If you don't understand that, I hope you are fired. How THE HELL is this allowed to happen.... The hours spent inputting the word (by all)... the common usefulness of the word... the flagrant disrespect of their sacrifice... There are no words..... *gross and utter negligence                             Semper Fi   

(You might want to look into this, this can't be allowed to happen: @Nikki Santoro                @Col Needham  )

Oldest First
Selected Oldest First

Employee

 • 

8.7K Messages

 • 

197.5K Points

11 hours ago

Please can you explain the problem in more detail? The keyword is still located at https://www.imdb.com/search/title/?keywords=u.s.-marine-corps&explore=keywords (with 1,100+ titles).

Are you saying that titles have been incorrectly removed from the keyword? If so, do you have a few (preferably high profile) example titles so we can take a look?  

(edited)

34 Messages

 • 

1K Points

The keyword has been removed entirely from the database, and thus 1000's of titles (every title it was assigned to). I would now have to add 'u.s.-marine' as "a new keyword". (This is how I discovered it was gone.)

A 'U.S. Marine' is an individual soldier who serves in the United States Marine Corps (U.S. Marine Corps), which is the naval infantry service branch of the U.S. Armed Forces. 

Whereas the 'U.S. Marine Corps' is a whole military service (like an army unto itself) comprised of its own infantry, aviation, artillery, air defense, logistics, communications, intelligence, cyber, engineering, medical, security, training, and recruiting units, as well as special operations forces. It carries a far broader meaning. The equivalent difference, as an example, would be like having kept the keyword 'U.S. Army' and deleted 'U.S. Soldier'. A very useful and significant keyword, as I'm sure you understand ...as was 'U.S. Marine'.

Needless to say, there are infinite scenarios where an individual 'U.S. Marine' is applicable as a 'Plot Detail' and not the entire 'U.S. Marine Corps'. Such as, where a U.S. Marine appears by himself, without the plot involving or showing the Marine Corps etc.

An example of a title where I know for a fact 'u.s.-marine' was assigned, from my own submission records, was The Pacific (TV Mini Series 2010) - Keywords - IMDb

(Although this is not an example of a title that only requires 'u.s.-marine' as 'u.s. marine corps' is assigned here also.)

Champion

 • 

17.2K Messages

 • 

360.1K Points

@Sir_Launcelot​ 

archive.org's copies of the page for The Pacific, ranging from 2009 to 2022, don't include u.s.-marine, only u.s.-marine-corps or united-states-marine-corps. If you had added it later it may have been changed by someone else.

159 titles had u.s.-marine in 2021:

https://web.archive.org/web/20210219152310/https://www.imdb.com/search/keyword/?keywords=u.s.-marine

Considering there is also marine, u.s.-soldier and other adjacent keywords, I don't think I would consider u.s.-marine essential.

(edited)

80 Messages

 • 

950 Points

This thread indicates when it was proposed for merging it had only 32 titles: https://community-imdb.sprinklr.com/conversations/data-issues-policy-discussions/duplicate-keywords-list-59-american-us-keywords-proposals-for-permanent-merger-and-autoconversion/63657f6c5c8f315ee268bf4d

I guess it was manually merged and cleaned up after that thread.

Champion

 • 

17.2K Messages

 • 

360.1K Points

@ashh2​ 

I think there was both u.s.-marine and u.s.-marines; only the latter was proposed merged.

80 Messages

 • 

950 Points

@Peter_pbn​ oh you're right, I think it was probably merged during same cleanup

473 Messages

 • 

9.2K Points

@Peter_pbn​ 

"Considering there is also marine, u.s.-soldier and other adjacent keywords, I don't think I would consider u.s.-marine essential."

That all depends on who is using the database,

for me watching a movie maybe not.

But if someone is to make a documentary about specific soldiers from the u.s.-marine,

or for some other reason are looking for footage of specifically portrayal of  u.s.-marine persons

finding all titles about u.s.-soldier would not be the same.

 

Also marine does not necessarily mean a soldier, that could just be a film about marine life,

meaning anything to do with the sea. 

473 Messages

 • 

9.2K Points