msmooreski1's profile

28 Messages

 • 

462 Points

Sunday, October 25th, 2026

No Status

0

In Quotes: Stage-direction brackets add unwanted line breaks [formatting]

I did search around for this as a reported issue or established conversation, and didn't see one. Maybe I'm bad at searching or maybe it's the search function, hard to say. Anyway. This is what I'm seeing. I entered a RARE, unusually-long Quote recently between several people that includes a lot of physical (unspoken) indicators that I rendered in square brackets. I just don't like how use of this punctuation for "stage directions" adds line breaks and re-states the Speaker. Example: 

Polly: It's too hot in here, I can't get any air. 

Polly: [fakes fainting]

Polly: Oh, my stars! 

I don't like it for these reasons: It adds unnecessarily to the overall vertical height of the Quote block: by introducing new lines, by breaking my example into three lines, each with space between them too. It breaks up the flow of the exchange and requires more scrolling. And it can be confusing for what should be (in theory) one line, like my example, to be rendered with three Speaker fields listed: that is, three lines in a row starting Polly, in what should be (in theory) continuous. 

I would prefer if the use of square brackets didn't introduce line breaks. If I can add this elsewhere as a problem or suggestion, please let me know and pardon my ignorance in advance. Thank you. 

Oldest First
Selected Oldest First

Champion

 • 

17.2K Messages

 • 

360K Points

28 days ago

Yeah, I'm not sure why that happens.

28 Messages

 • 

462 Points

@Peter_pbn​  I have no way of knowing if this is new (I doubt it), but this Discussion made me notice that during new Quote submission from Episode-level, these IMDb guidelines: 

  • If you are including stage directions to set the scene for a quote, please remember to enclose them in [square brackets].
  • Please do not use separate lines for directions.
  • Please do not use separate lines for multiple sentences spoken by the same character.

What a coincidence! That is exactly what the use of square brackets DOES within Quotes: IMDb DOES starts new separate line after a [bracketed stage direction]; Likewise, if user includes a [bracketed stage direction] within a Quote, IMDb DOES split multiple sentences spoken by the same character into separate lines. 

Champion

 • 

17.2K Messages

 • 

360K Points

I posted a question about part of those guidelines last year because it seems inconsistent with the help page, but there has been no further reply:

https://community-imdb.sprinklr.com/conversations/data-issues-policy-discussions/quote-directions/69246f7042ac581477055632

I think stage directions should be able to be added inline or on separate lines depending on the content, and they should probably be displayed the way they were submitted.