Find a series or film title based on known scenes

I don’t remember much of the premise but I know in the flashbacks, the two main guys are white, one kinda has that 1990s Brad renfro/skeet ulrich look, they’re in high school together and they’re on the wrestling team. It’s obvious they have a thing for each other but they both have girlfriends. And then one day they go out and about and the 90s heart throb takes them to a gay bar and they get drunk and dance and make out. And when the non ulrich guy keeps dating his girl the ulrich guy gets super aggressive during wrestling. Heeeelp, I know it was out in 2025 or 2026, and the flashbacks are set in the 1990s. It was definitely on a streamer but I can’t remember which one.