9 Messages
•
422 Points
You Tube entires should not be allowed to masquerade as TV series
It seems as if there are too many television IMdb credits given to people who appear in "You Tube" videos. These are You Tube videos not television. As such there should be a separate designation for "Web series" so as not to confuse them with legitimate television credits.
MykolaYeriomin
Champion
•
4K Messages
•
244.1K Points
7 years ago
I understand your concerns and separating web and TV would have probably been a good idea... ten or five years ago. Nowadays content on YouTube and numerous other platforms is not only rivaling traditional television, it sometimes gets a bigger audience and gives content as much prominence. Some platforms are so borderline that if IMDb will implement "web series" there will be endless disputes and arguments about TV vs. Web as a status of certain project (that basically is the situation with Netflix, Hulu, Amazon and some of the Adult Swim productions).
I am personally adding a lot of YouTube content on IMDb however I have personal standards on that matter, trying to add productions with either some production values or cultural significance/appeal. The latter might seem speculative and subjective, but really, some YouTube videos or rather short films or episodes began worldwide-known franchises and subgenres while some TV shows got closed on their first season failing to amass half-an-audience of what a talented YouTuber can do with a single video.
3
brian_distance
9 Messages
•
422 Points
7 years ago
1
jeorj_euler
10.7K Messages
•
225.4K Points
6 years ago
6
jay_spirit
1K Messages
•
29.9K Points
5 years ago
I agree with Nikolay Yeriomin that the distinction between a web series and a TV series can be blurry, but I'd still like to make it. I've been adding YouTube and other online content for two years, and it still feels weird to tick the "TV series" box when I'm adding a web series.
In fact, I wonder why we have the same category - "Video" - for both an online video and a movie that was originally released to VHS or DVD. I'd like to see all online content, including both standalone videos and series, in a category called "Web" or "Internet" or "Online". (Hat tip: Luka1184).
1