32 Messages
•
450 Points
Where is my review?
I submitted a review yesterday and it didn't show up. I'm sure I followed all the rules. I tried again today and it still isn't here.
32 Messages
•
450 Points
I submitted a review yesterday and it didn't show up. I'm sure I followed all the rules. I tried again today and it still isn't here.
Vchimpanzee1
32 Messages
•
450 Points
4 years ago
I see "declined" with the first submission but I can't see anything I did that was wrong. It says "pending" with the second.
8
bderoes
Champion
•
5.1K Messages
•
118.6K Points
4 years ago
If you want to contribute a plot synopsis, just Edit the title page, and select Plot Synopsis, found under the category Plot & Quotes.
1
0
Vchimpanzee1
32 Messages
•
450 Points
4 years ago
I just checked and I have two reviews of the same movie "Pending". One was submitted Monday when I thought something had gone wrong. I had seen the message "Sorry, your review is too short" before typing anything, and one time when that happened I think the review didn't get submitted. The other review was submitted after I was given advice about what was wrong.
0
0
Vchimpanzee1
32 Messages
•
450 Points
4 years ago
And let me add that merely posting the plot summary is not a satisfactory solution for me. Even if there was not one, mine is told from my point of view, which in a way is an evaluation of the movie, if not what you would call a review. And what I want to say is too long. Maybe for some people, what would be considered spoilers would be included. If I am reviewing a movie for which imdb has little information, I won't post a spoiler warning but will be careful to avoid what many might consider spoilers. Unfortunately, for a few movies my long review is the only information imdb has other than the credits. It may be true that my review is the only information online anywhere. If imdb wants to lose that for other movies, they're coming close to doing so.
1
0
Vchimpanzee1
32 Messages
•
450 Points
4 years ago
I checked again and both reviews were declined. I made changes by actually expressing opinions this time on the movie early in the review. Since I've never had a problem with similar reviews before, imdb now owes me an explanation. This is not a case where I can look at the guidelines and see anything wrong. If imdb doesn't want my reviews, I will take my ball and go home. They can keep my past reviews, but I won't subject myself to this again. If imdb doesn't want to have any information whatsoever on certain movies, that is exactly what they will have.
3
Vchimpanzee1
32 Messages
•
450 Points
4 years ago
Like I said, the reviews did not violate anything before. If they had a problem, they should have had a problem a long time ago. And I can't simply replace someone else's plot summary.
5
Vchimpanzee1
32 Messages
•
450 Points
4 years ago
I just had a review approved. That was fast. Now apparently I know how to do it right.
2