tejas_nair's profile

58 Messages

 • 

1.6K Points

Wednesday, September 9th, 2020 12:26 PM

Closed

Where can I check deleted reviews?

I remember we used to have a feature where deleted reviews (for any reason) would show up as a list. Is there a way to check that now?

 

I am asking because I had posted a review for this title back in October 2019. It was the oldest review on this title but now it's gone (suspiciously on the day of the film's online premiere). No reason or intimation was provided. And now I had to resubmit one.

 

Can you please help me retrieve it? Plus, help me with the reason as well? I'll take down the new one then.

 

Thanks.

189 Messages

 • 

6K Points

4 years ago

I haven't had reviews removed, but many folks have reported that here.   Why can't IMDb use a bare minimum of common courtesy to send an automated email to the original contributor when a significant contribution is removed?  Preferably with a specific reason.  The current system is so incredibly rude.

Employee

 • 

17.5K Messages

 • 

313.3K Points

4 years ago

Hi Tejas_nair -

 

Currently, there is no option for you to see deleted reviews.

 

I can confirm that your recent submitted review for "Cargo" was approved and is now displaying on the title page:

 

Regarding your previously deleted review, this is the Review text:

 

Cargo, produced like a skit on a low budget, is a snoozefest that is not clear about its objective. It starts off with an aspiration to be a sci-fi drama about loneliness in the space where the protagonist (Vikrant Massey), a staff at an imaginary post-death transition services agency, has been spending decades and working solo in a breathing spacecraft named Pushkar something without much contact with the outer world. Then it aims higher and brings in another character (Shweta Tripathi) and scrambles to turn itself into an emotional story about companionship and how ignorance is not always bliss. Without enough background to the story, the plot (where dead people are sent to this transition agency and then sent back home as a new person in optionally some other form) - which is quite zany, to be fair to the director - does not explain things that are essential for its upkeep and interest and just fumbles every now and then until one of the three main characters utters a few words of philosophy and/or existentialism while sipping cola from a McDonald's plastic cup. I understand the restrictions low budget can put on the production but watching Cargo reminded me of those substandard comedy skits that they play on Indian national television during primetime with canned laughter in the form of a human being as its main character. Even the spacesuits look like they were made out of bed sheets. That skilled actors like Massey and Tripathi are not utilized well shows the additional lack of efforts put in the writing and the direction. Nothing gels in the avant-garde hopeful that this film turns out to be but falls extremely short of every single ingredient except for maybe the score. Watch the HBO drama Six Feet Under (2001) and space stuff Gravity (2013) again and forget that Cargo even existed and that Vikramaditya Motwane or Anurag Kashyap helped produce this technical vomit for laymen. TN. (Watched and reviewed at its world premiere at the 21st MAMI Mumbai Film Festival.)

 

Cheers!

8.5K Messages

 • 

176.2K Points

@ Michelle

  

From another User a long time ago:

you could see which of your reviews got reported and deleted. 

http://www.imdb.com/user/ur000000/comments-deleted

 

Would this be helpful now ? ?

Added Jan 25 2021:

Horst
https://community-imdb.sprinklr.com/users/5f49561cc17a0660597f7c72

Thu, Dec 21, 2017
https://community-imdb.sprinklr.com/conversations/data-issues-policy-discussions/is-there-any-way-right-now-to-find-out-if-one-of-your-reviews-got-reporteddeleted/5f4a79de8815453dba8d9b61

Is there any way right now to find out if one of your reviews got reported/deleted?
like you could previously on

http://www.imdb.com/user/ur0000000/comments-deleted

Has anybody here had one of his reviews deleted recently and gotten any heads-up per email or so?
If not, I would like to suggest this as an idea for the future!

.

 

 

(edited)

Employee

 • 

17.5K Messages

 • 

313.3K Points

Hi Act_1 -

 

Unfortunately, no, this link is no longer operational for deleted reviews.

14 Messages

 • 

474 Points

3 years ago

Why can't IMDb use a bare minimum of common courtesy to send an automated email to the original contributor when a significant contribution is removed?  Preferably with a specific reason.  The current system is so incredibly rude.

10.7K Messages

 • 

225.4K Points

To be fair, I should point out that maybe such a feature will someday exist. Right now, we can be reasonably certain that implementing it is nowhere to be found on the IMDb developers' undisclosed long list of priorities.