What’s wrong with this contribution? (New Tricks/Dead Man Talking)

I tried to contributed this, but was declined: The writers obviously forgot about Season 1 episode 6 and how bad they were burned with their run in with that "psychic". In that episode Jack was a total believer, Sandra was the skeptic, and it is reversed in this episode. But then I looked and see that someone else posted this - and it was accepted….I’m not sure why mine above was declined - and whoever below got approved.: The writers really should have watched the series before writing for it. The last time UCOS had a case involving a clairvoyant it was Jack who brought it to Sandra, after he'd visited one to talk try and contact Mary. He believed in the power of clairvoyants then, and the man was proven right, which wouldn't have made Jack a sceptic.