REVIEW PROCESS IS BLATANTLY RIGGED

SOMEONE IS RIGGING THE REVIEW PROCESS. I have tried to review SHE-HULK: ATTORNEY AT LAW - 4 TIMES WITH A POSITIVE REVIEW!! My first three reviews (each written differently) were all rejected for allegedly violating submission guidelines even though nothing I said was remotely offensive or violated IMDb submission guideline policy (I know because I read the submission rules to make sure). And yet - negative reviewers were able to post blatantly hateful and misogynistic comments - including bashing on Disney's "woke" agenda (quoted words written in negative reviews that were published and did not violate submission guidelines). So to test my theory that positive reviews were being denied - I wrote a PERFECT REVIEW (see review below). THIS TIME IT WAS DENIED "REASON NOT SPECIFIED." So basically IMDb's user reviews are NOT correctly reflecting all their users' opinions because reviews are purposefully being blocked depending upon if the IMDb employee allowing the review to be posted likes or doesn't like the show being reviewed personally. BTW - I have a second IMDb account under a different email - and guess what - positive review of She-Hulk - DENIED.

USER REVIEW ADDITION

TITLE: FUNNY AND CLEVER - CUTE SHOW OVERALL - HIGHLY RECOMMEND

If you watch the show with an open mind, then you will enjoy it. Many of the negative comments are about who produces it and not the show itself. The show itself has a quirky and clever premise. I like a strong but flawed heroine who sticks up for herself but is also self-deprecating at times. There are a lot of quick-witted one-liners that made me laugh out loud. Is it going to win an Emmy? No - but if you just want some fun, mindless entertainment that actually entertains, this is the show for you. Also - if you are a die-hard Marvel fan - please keep an open mind and appreciate the show for what it is rather than finding all the plot flaws. Life is to be enjoyed - and this show is joyful.

SUBMISSION DENIED: Reason Not specified

Your contribution has been declined. We did not capture a specific reason during processing

Responses

ACT_1

8.5K Messages

•

176.2K Points

2 years ago

@roxygirl5150
Joined on Aug 25, 2022
- - -

? ?

Your reviews...

Post the 18-digit ID from
Your Update History:
https://contribute.imdb.com/updates/history

Your Contribution History:

https://contribute.imdb.com/contributions/history

- - -

juanquaglia
Joined Thu, Sep 1, 2022
https://community-imdb.sprinklr.com/users/63109789c5eeb86e2c3c0e3a

Thu, Sep 1, 2022

My review disappeared
I posted a review for She-Hulk: Attorney at Law.
It was one of the top reviews, with over 1,700 votes.
It didn't violate any policy.
The review title was
"Marvel is making mistakes in character development".
Today I've noticed the review just disappeared.
I never received any notification of such deletion.
Why was it deleted?

https://community-imdb.sprinklr.com/conversations/data-issues-policy-discussions/my-review-disappeared/6310987bc5eeb86e2c3c0e4c

juanquaglia
IMDb member since May 2015
https://www.imdb.com/user/ur60215872/

https://www.imdb.com/user/ur60215872/reviews - 43 Reviews

Review of She-Hulk: Attorney at Law
She's not a superhero
1 September 2022
https://www.imdb.com/review/rw8503247/

- - -

She-Hulk: Attorney at Law (2022- )
https://www.imdb.com/title/tt10857160/

https://www.imdb.com/title/tt10857160/reference/

https://www.imdb.com/title/tt10857160/reviews?sort=submissionDate - 901 Reviews

https://www.imdb.com/title/tt10857160/ratings

User Ratings
IMDb Users
64,796 IMDb users have given a weighted average vote of 5.0 / 10
Rating Votes
10 21.4% 13,860
1 36.8% 23,855

.

(edited)

0

F

Fran

Employee

•

2.5K Messages

•

26.2K Points

2 years ago

Hello roxygirl5150,

Could you help us posting the 18-digits submission reference number? for our staff to take a look for you!

You can find the reference number on your Contribution History page.

1

roxygirl5150

6 Messages

•

112 Points

@Fran

Dear Fran,

Per your request - here are the submission reference numbers for the 4 submissions that I made under this account that were rejected. They are in order of newest submission (the one that was randomly rejected without given a reason, and is written out in my original post) to the oldest submission listed last (all three of the last submissions allegedly rejected for violating submission guidelines even though NOTHING I wrote could be considered offensive, hate speech, personal attack etc). Thank you for investigating this issue.

Contribution Confirmation - Submission made on 9/1/2022

Contribution #220901-153319-425104

Contribution Confirmation - Submission made on 08/30/2022

Contribution #220831-013940-260004

Contribution Confirmation - Submission made on 08/27/2022

Contribution #220827-134404-729404

Contribution Confirmation - Submission made on 08/25/2022

Contribution #220826-012647-761604

(edited)

2 years ago

0

F

Fran

Employee

•

2.5K Messages

•

26.2K Points

2 years ago

Hello roxygirl5150,

Thanks for posting the reference numbers! I have checked the submission numbers,

as per the User Reviews policies, writing is all-caps is not allowed, also we do not allow reviews not focused on the movie content or reviewing other reviews live on the page. The contributions provided are rejected due to the reasons above.

3

0

roxygirl5150

6 Messages

•

112 Points

@Fran I find your response absurd. I have written many reviews with all capitals and also stating to ignore negative reviews - and they were always posted. I think that the nitpicking - if it really was and not blatant favoritism against She-Hulk and Disney - is absurd to the level of being a joke and mockery of the review process itself. I will be happy to resubmit - let's see what happens when I don't use caps or make a comment on negative reviews. ALSO (sorry for the caps) - I find it beyond contemptable that I was refused 4 submissions for using something as innocuous as capital letters and telling people not to believe the negative reviews when numerous posts against She-Hulk and Disney mentioned Disney's "woke" agenda. How is this not hate speech and intolerance? Why weren't these reviews rejected?? I can't use capital letters, but someone can trash Disney's liberal views??? Not to mention all of the blatant misogynistic comments against women. Hypocritical to say the least.

2 years ago

0

roxygirl5150

6 Messages

•

112 Points

@Fran Here are a good examples of IMDb allowing people to post blatantly hostile and politically motivated comments - including one trashing our current president. And yet - no policy violation. Hmmm......

This was posted on Aug. 23 by vfgsszb

2/10

Disney+ please stop with these awful shows

vfgsszb23 August 2022

This was as bad as I feared it would be.

The writing stunk, the acting was poor, the storyline yikes, the main character is boring, and let's face it, besides black panther, the Hulk is my least favorite Avenger/Marvel character, and listening to Mark Ruffalo talk is like listening to Joe Biden try to spit out a complete and comprehensive sentence.

I have no interest in watching anymore episodes, and I'm willing to bet Ms Marvel is just as bad too.

ANOTHER REVIEW - CITING DISNEY BEING "WOKE" - USES THE WORD "WOKE" AND "WOKENESS" SEVERAL TIMES IN A DEFMATORY WAY (sorry for capitals yet again).

1/10

Yuck🤢

avinash-3059629 August 2022

Did not expect from Marvel, Disney making everything woke and Bad that it touches.

I don't want this kind of Content why are you forcing this to us?

When I first heard that there would be a She-Hulk show I kinda was interested, because I remember She-Hulk fondly from back in the 90s till late 2000s.

Then I remembered what happened since the early till mid 2010 with her in comics and how woke Disney has become these days, so my interest was gone but I'm about to get into collecting old comic books for some reason.

It's the same thing with me and Moon Knight. I've become a huge fan of the character in the last few years, and I was thrilled when I found out he was finally getting his own show. But they completely dropped the ball on it, and since then, I haven't had confidence in anything Disney does anymore.

Daredevil is one of my all-time favorite characters, and I don't even want to see him in the MCU because I'm afraid of what they'll do with him.

They took what should have been a supernatural vigilante show and turned it into the typical Disney spectacle. And I really disliked Layla. She was basically a Disney OC who was inserted into the plot for wokeness points. That whole bit in the finale where she becomes an avatar is one of the stupidest things I've ever seen in a TV show.

Another review commenting on a "woke" joke:

1/10

Terrible

sifonr24 August 2022

I struggled a lot finishing the first episode. A woke joke as all the marvel movies/shows for the past decade.

Terrible writing, bad jokes and I almost died of cringing at the end.

Stay away people, you will have more entertainment reading FN's Climate change and that says a lot.

And a final blatantly hostile and hateful post:

1/10

Its a burning pile of trash.

codyrobertson-8919729 August 2022

This is whats wrong with the current state of Marvel. Series like this should not exist, the writers are pretty much shoving their opinions and beliefs down your throat, and if you don't like it your a misogynist or a bigot or a racist or some other "ist"... I use to love Marvel movies for the simple entertainment they provided, now i feel like I'm forced into some re-education camp while watching them and forced to hate myself if i dislike it.

I miss the days of Iron Man, Black Widow, Hawk Eye, Thor and a Raging Hulk that provided a good story with some highs and lows and maybe even learn something along the way. Now that Disney has a hold of Marvel, its just going to get worse and worse...I use to love Disney and now I absolutely detest them. Stop it Disney...Get some help and see what you're doing to many of the fans that lived and breathed these stories and characters since childhood.

@FRAN - get my point on why I am annoyed and think your review process is a hypocritical joke??

2 years ago

0

F

Fran

Employee

•

2.5K Messages

•

26.2K Points

Hello roxygirl5150,

If you have observed other User Reviews posted to the site which are in direct violation of our User Review guidelines, you are welcome to report them by clicking the "Report this" link below the review and our staff will investigate further.

2 years ago

0

roxygirl5150

REVIEW PROCESS IS BLATANTLY RIGGED

ACT_1

Fran

roxygirl5150

Contribution Confirmation - Submission made on 08/30/2022

Contribution Confirmation - Submission made on 08/27/2022

Contribution Confirmation - Submission made on 08/25/2022

Fran

roxygirl5150

roxygirl5150

Fran

Related Conversations

Helpful Widget