111 Messages
•
1.5K Points
Punctuation for multi-line titles
What should be the punctuation separator for a multi-part title, where the parts are clearly separate, and are displayed on separate lines?
Does it depend on the country or language?
I've seen a dash (or hyphen), a colon, and a comma. Such punctuation isn't on display on-screen, but used on IMDb and elsewhere in print when you need to refer to the title in a single line of text. But what's the convention? Or is there one?
For example:
https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0063665/
The new title for this is
The Rolling Stones
Sympathy for the Devil
Clearly there is a separation between two parts of this title. However, it was listed on IMDb as run together without punctuation. I changed it to add a hyphen separator. I chose the hyphen because the AKA for the Germany DVD used a hyphen:
211224-121000-550000
The Rolling Stones - Sympathy for the Devil
In the comment box I wrote:
"Added implied punctuation (used by convention to separate title parts on two separate lines in the movie credits). Using a hyphen as in the Germany DVD title also listed on this IMDb page."
It was Approved, but when the site updated I saw the hyphen was instead a colon:
The Rolling Stones: Sympathy for the Devil
When I tried to change the colon into a hyphen,
211230-094013-481000
it was Declined for being "Badly Formatted".
Really? What IS the proper format? Should the Germany DVD listing also be changed to a colon? Or is a hyphen the proper convention for German titles in text, but not in English? Who says English should use a colon? What about other languages (like French)? I've seen a comma used in many cases. Are these interchangeable? Does it matter?
An interesting side-note is that in printing French, a space is always included before a colon (and before a question mark too), as if the colon acted like a dash (or hyphen).
And as a point of order, when using a dash in text anywhere, note this is not a hyphen. A hyphen is a different symbol shorter in length and used to divide a compound word in English or French (German just runs the words together), or to divide between syllables for end-of-line printing. A dash is a syntactical punctuation. However, IMDb automatically uses a hyphen symbol in place of a dash.
Is there any standardization in single line text punctuation in title part separation in the field, and does IMDb convention follow this or have its own?





mbmb
1.7K Messages
•
22.9K Points
4 years ago
https://help.imdb.com/article/contribution/titles/title-formatting/G56U5ERK7YY47CQB
4