1 Message
•
72 Points
Possible unusual voting pattern for The Odyssey
Hello IMDb,
I have a question regarding the voting pattern for The Odyssey.
The film currently has a weighted IMDb rating of 8.3, but the ratings distribution seems unusual. 36.6% of users have rated it 10/10, 22.6% have rated it 9/10, and 14.3% have rated it 8/10. In contrast, all ratings from 2/10 to 6/10 combined account for only about 7.2% of the votes, while 13.9% of all votes are 1/10.
It seems unusual that there are almost twice as many 1/10 ratings as all ratings from 2/10 through 6/10 combined. I understand that some users genuinely dislike the film, but this distribution looks unusual, so I was wondering if IMDb has reviewed this title for possible review bombing or other suspicious voting activity.
I know IMDb uses a weighted rating system and does not publicly disclose how it works. I’m simply asking whether this voting pattern has been looked at, as it appears quite unusual.
Thank you for your time


Kristin
337 Messages
•
7.3K Points
1 month ago
Hello.
Fellow user here, while we await the answer from IMDb,
i would just like to point out that the "Unweighted mean" is 7.7
as seen here:
https://www.imdb.com/title/tt33764258/ratings/
So the system has clearly not counted every of the low votes so something has been detected :-)
0
Fran
Employee
•
4.4K Messages
•
44.6K Points
1 month ago
Hi!
Thank you for bringing this to our attention. Our voting system already detects and defeats attempts to stuff the ballot and skew the rating, as demonstrated by the difference between the weighted average and the arithmetic mean on the vast majority of titles in the database.
For additional information about IMDb ratings and weighted averages, please refer to our FAQ here: https://help.imdb.com/article/imdb/track-movies-tv/ratings-faq/G67Y87TFYYP6TWAV
0
0
LutherJoy
21 Messages
•
340 Points
1 month ago
If the modal rating cluster (10 - 8) constitutes 73.5% of all votes - and the intervening possible values of (6 - 2) are only 7.2% of votes - 13.9% 1/10 votes is an impossible natural curve
10 > 9 > 8 > *1 > 7 > 6 > 5 > 4
* - there are more than 200% as many 1s as 7s, yet almost as many 1s as 8s - bidirectionally deviant from the rest of the trend
The false inflection is clear; - all 1/10 votes outside the rational statistical range for the title are internally inconsistent with the total trend and should be weighted with a 0 coefficient, not any nonzero alternative.
Especially in context of external evidence of a coordinated hate campaign against the film - highest frequencies of 1/10 ratings concur geographically with the peak consumption rates of hateful propaganda targeted against the film's casting choices.
Unpolarized locations exhibit unimodal rating curves.
The true weighted mean for The Odyssey (2026) at the current number of votes is closer to 8.97/10 without the statistically incoherent 1/10 votes.
And hate is being permitted to erase this cultural moment.
Its true 9/10 rating would rouse millions more of fence-straddlers to go watch The Odyssey (2026), as it would be coherent with the ~9.4/10 critical, box office and non-IMDb audience metrics - which are crucially; viewing-verified.
More importantly IMDb must implement voter viewing verification.
(edited)
3
Soh
1 Message
•
60 Points
1 month ago
I feel the same about the people that Voted 10 for a Movie.
All Ratings for 1 and 10 should be removed from the Total Rating of The Odyssey. As it currently stands the current Rating is fabricated and needs to be recalculated. It would have much worse Rating if all those Fake 10 Ratings weren't added to the total Score.
2
0
LutherJoy
21 Messages
•
340 Points
1 month ago
Ratings must be assessed for various markers of internal and external coherence with -
SECTION 1:
1) the film externally (eg critical ratings, audience ratings, etc)
1a - The Odyssey (2026) scored a 94% Tomatometer rating - from 431 critics - with an average critic rating of 8.7/10 - the latter score rarer - even for 100% Tomatometers
1a - ii - The Odyssey (2026) retains a 97% Popcornmeter at >10,000 verified ratings - a weaker but still significant metric
The 10/10 votes that have resulted in the film's 8.5/10 IMDb rating - are in fact offset by the stuffed 1s
1b - The Odyssey (2026) scored an 88% metacritic rating - which isn't linearly mappable to IMDb ratings - but in concert with other similar external ratings - reinforces the conclusion of an artificially low 8.5/10 IMDb rating, offset by the false 1s
1c - The Odyssey (2026) is rated 4.4/5 or 8.8/10 on letterboxhd;
the overall global external verdict trends toward upper 8s (8.7 - 8.9)/10 - not middle 8s
SECTION 2:
2) films at 7-days old and over time on IMDb
2a - i)
On November 18th 2014 - 4 days into its release -
Christopher Nolan's Interstellar had an IMDb rating of 9/10 with 220,000 votes
On 15th February 2015 - Christopher Nolan's Interstellar had an IMDb rating of 8.8/10
11.5 years later - the film is rated 8.7/10 with ~ 2,600,000 votes
2a - ii)
In February 2015 -
451,896 IMDb users had given Christopher Nolan's Interstellar (2014) a weighted average vote of 8.8 / 10
46% of those 451,896 votes were 10/10 (201k/452k 10s)
1% were 1s
Early 10/10 : 1/10 Ratio for Christopher Nolan's Interstellar (2014) -
46:1
2b)
On September 02 2008 - Christopher Nolan's 1.5 month old The Dark Knight (2008) had a IMDb rating of 9.1/10 with 260K votes
Nearly 2 decades later - in July 2026 - The Dark Knight (2008) still has an IMDb rating of 9.1/10, with ~ 3,200,000 votes
18 years earlier -
260,763 IMDb users had given Christopher Nolan's The Dark Knight (2008) a weighted average vote of 9.1 / 10
63% were 10/10
2c)
On September 10th 2010 - Christopher Nolan's 1.8 month old Inception (2010) had a 9.1/10 IMDb rating with 175K votes
175,068 IMDb users had given Christopher Nolan's Inception (2010) weighted average vote of 9.1 / 10
61% of those 175,068 votes were 10/10 (107k/175k 10s)
1% were 1s
Early 10/10 : 1/10 Ratio for Christopher Nolan's Inception (2010) -
61:1
VS
The Odyssey (2026)
for which -
34% of votes are 10s (statistically low for early Christopher Nolan ratings)
9% of votes are 1s - which is statistically inconsistent within the system itself
Early 10/10 : 1/10 Ratio for Christopher Nolan's The Odyssey (2026) -
4:1
here's where it gets more interesting
The Prestige (2006) - which shares The Odyssey (2026)'s current 8.5/10 and rating
The Prestige (2006)
10/10 - 24% of votes
9/10 - 32% of votes
8/10 - 27% of votes
1/10 - <0.5% of votes
*doubly interestingly - The Prestige (2006) had a lower initial IMDb rating - and rose over time (as more people appreciated the plot and character intricacies over time); like The Odyssey (2026) so far (as more people actually see the film over time)
SECITON 3:
3) the filmmaker himself:
any extrapolative statistical model would account for Nolan's previous IMDb ratings - the highest within his vote number ranges for any filmmaker in history;
Christopher Nolan's top 6 titles by IMDb rating are -
9.1/10 with 3.2 million votes,
8.8/10 with 2.8 million votes,
8.7/10 with 2.6 million votes,
8.5/10 with 1.6 million votes,
8.5/10 with 201k votes - The Odyssey (2026) on 24th July 2026, 7 days after its release
8.4/10 with 2 million votes
The argument isn't that he can't make a film of lower voter score -
but that this rating -
-8.5/10 with
-34% of the votes as 10s - is fewer 10s than statistically predictable - but statistically coherent for the filmmaker within the same system
but
-9% as of the votes as 1s; is not statistically coherent with
i - any Christopher Nolan titles historically
ii - ratings of the film externally
iii - any films rated 8.5/10 at any point in time
iv - films rated 8.5/10 early on IMDb
v - films with 34% 10/10 votes
vi - films with 94% Tomatometers
vi - films with 8.7/10 critic ratings - rare, even for 100% Tomatometer ratings
vii - films with 88% metacritic scores
etc
In fact - the longterm 10/10 : 1/10 longterm percentage ratios for his other films
The Dark Knight (2008)
10/10 - 46% of votes (1,500,000 10s)
1/10 - 1% of votes (41,000 1s)
18 Year 10/10 : 1/10 Ratio for Christopher Nolan's The Dark Knight (2008) -
46:1
Inception (2010)
10/10 - 34% of votes (about 1,000,000 10s)
9/10 - 36% of votes (about 900,000 9s)
1/10 - 1% of votes (about 23,000 1s)
16 Year 10/10 : 1/10 Ratio for Christopher Nolan's Inception (2010) -
34:1
70:1 for (10, 9):1
Interstellar (2014)
10/10 - 40% of votes (about 1,000,000 10s)
1/10 - 1% of votes (about 19,000 1s)
12 Year 10/10 : 1/10 Ratio for Christopher Nolan's Interstellar (2014)
40:1
10/10 : 1/10 RATIOS over time for Christopher Nolan's titles above
Inception (2010) in 2010
47% 10s
1% 1s
47:1
Inception (2010) in 2026
34% 10s
1% 1s
34:1
Interstellar (2014) in 2014
61% 10s
1% 1s
61:1
Interstellar (2014) in 2026
40% 10s
1% 1s
40:1
for his Christopher Nolan's directly prior to The Odyssey (2026)
Oppenheimer (2023) in 2023
10/10 - 43%
9/10 - 28%
8/10 - 17%
1/10 - 1%
Oppenheimer (2023) in 2026
10/10 - 24%
9/10 - 26%
8/10 - 29%
1/10 - 1%
For rating behavior over time;
these rating trends across titles prove that
1) early >40% 10/10 votes are statistically coherent with Nolan's overall filmography, and other titles with high early IMDb ratings
-Nolan's films statistically settle with high IMDb ratings over time (uncommon with other filmmakers at average vote counts >1,000,000 - hence no other filmmakers share a comparable average rating at average votes >1,000,000 per title)
but
2) but >2% - let alone 9% 1/10 votes - are statistically unprecedented - neither years after the film's release - and never days into the film's release - for a rating with significant early 10s
The early 10s emerge from the theatrical experience (visual and sonic immersion) - for which Christopher Nolan films - as per various sources (industry, critical, audience and other perspectives) and metrics (categories of award nominations) - are objectively optimized
-this is statistically true of titles such as Top Gun: Maverick (2022), The Avengers: Infinity War (2018) and Avengers: Endgame (2019) - that according to audiences excel at immersive action spectacle
9s emerge from technically-precise highly emotive narratives as experienced on home media -
-films that are more storycentric score early and persistent 9s (Django Unchained (2012), Parasite (2019) etc)) - where efficient (award-nominated, critic-cited) cinematography, editing etc result in consistent emotivity
Films that score highly in the high-level dimensions of (story, spectacle, scale) - score persistent 10s (and stabilize at >400K votes in the 8.5 - 9.3 range) - that secondarily emerge from advancements in home theatre immersion that approximate the original cinematic experience more closely over time: a number of Nolan's films exist within this statistically rare subcategory (fewer than 70 out of millions of films made over the past 130+ years)
Nolan's films exhibit a rare statistical pattern - in which IMDb ratings either increase - or persist over time; a lot of films start as 8s and decline to 6s or 7s; Nolan's films - from empirical data sourced from millions of voters over decades - tend to retain the perceptual greatness even after transference to home media - hence the 9.1/10, 8.8/10, 8.7/10 etc ratings at >2,000,000 votes per title
For comparison - the lowest rated Nolan film
Insomnia (2002) - has 0.4% 1s
SECTION 4:
Recent non-Nolan titles with high IMDb ratings:
Parasite (2019) in 2019
10/10 - 24%
9/10 - 34%
8/10 - 27%
1/10 - <1%
Parasite (2019) in 2026
10/10 - 24%
9/10 - 32%
8/10 - 26%
1/10 - <1%
Top Gun: Maverick (2022) in 2022
10/10 - 37%
9/10 - 30%
8/10 - 21%
1/10 - <1%
Top Gun: Maverick (2022) in 2026
10/10 - 24%
9/10 - 24%
8/10 - 30%
1/10 - <1%
Avengers: Infinity War (2018) in 2018
10/10 - 51%
9/10 - 23%
8/10 - 14%
1/10 - 2%
Avengers: Infinity War (2018) in 2026
10/10 - 32%
9/10 - 26%
8/10 - 23%
1/10 - 2%
Avengers: Endgame (2019) in 2019
10/10 - 45%
9/10 - 21%
8/10 - 16%
1/10 - 2%
Avengers: Endgame (2019) in 2026
10/10 - 33%
9/10 - 23%
8/10 - 21%
1/10 - 2%
for early IMDb ratings of highly rated titles -
1/10 votes are never 9% of ratings - rarely above 3% - generally around 1%
but 10/10 votes are often >30% of ratings
for stable ratings -
1/10 votes remain close to their original 0.5 - 2% range
and
10/10 trend toward a 22% - 34% range for films that end up in the 8.2 - 8.5 range:
-the 1/10 votes being 9% of votes for The Odyssey (2026) - is the statistical inconsistency;
-the 10/10 votes being 34% of votes - is statistically coherent with the rest of the system
The Odyssey (2026)'s 4:1 ratio of 10/10 : 1/10 votes is statistically inconsistent with Nolan's other early IMDb 10:1 ratios (46:1, 61:1, etc) - and more importantly inconsistent with the rest of The Odyssey (2026)'s external ratings by both verified viewers and critics on other sentiment aggregation sites - and other titles of similar ratings internally and externally - at any point along their ratings curves.
Note: This comment was created from a merged conversation Link : https://community-imdb.sprinklr.com/conversations/data-issues-policy-discussions/statistically-incoherent-percentage-of-110-votes-for-the-odyssey-2026/6a63a0294a49ebabfcb54da6 Title : Statistically Incoherent Percentage of 1/10 Votes for The Odyssey (2026)1