Please Respond - Help With A Review

Can someone please tell me what to do in regards to this review I've been trying to submit.

Is there anything wrong with the review in question. If so, then what do I need to fix, and how?

On a side note, a few times I tried to submit this review and it was rejected, I was told that it went against the guidelines because it mentioned real life events. What events? Besides, it's a World War II film, so what I was mentioning was relevant to the film's story. How is it possible to write a review relating to something about World War II without even mentioning anything relating to the war?

Again, please respond, I need to know what to do.

Thanks.

Responses

Oldest First

Selected Oldest First

F

Fran

Employee

•

4.1K Messages

•

42.1K Points

17 days ago

Hello Starwyvern77

Can you post the 18-digits submission reference number for the Review rejected? so we can take a look for you.

You can find your contributions in your Contributions History BETA page.

2

0

Starwyvern77

24 Messages

•

362 Points

@Fran It hasn't been rejected yet, I'm referring to some older posts I made on an older account.

If this review gets rejected, I'll be sure to inquire about it.

Like

Reply

17 days ago

0

Starwyvern77

24 Messages

•

362 Points

@Fran Here's the receipt, it was just rejected today.

And please, tell me what exactly it is that makes it ineligible. In addition, how is it possible to write a review about a movie relating to World War II without mentioning anything relating to the war, even if it's necessary to the film's story?

#260508-133010-334621

Like

Reply

15 days ago

0

Starwyvern77

24 Messages

•

362 Points

17 days ago

Hello, I have a problem relating to a review I submitted for a film called Edge of Darkness, 1943. Is there anything wrong with the review in question. If so, then what do I need to fix, and how? On a side note, a few times I tried to submit this review and it was rejected, I was told that it went against the guidelines because it mentioned real life events. What events? Besides, it's a World War II film, so what I was mentioning was relavent to the film's story. How is it possible to write a review relating to something about World War II without even mentioning anything relating to the war? Again, please respond, I need to know what to do. Thanks. Receipt: #260508-133010-334621 Note: This comment was created from a merged conversation Link : https://community-imdb.sprinklr.com/conversations/data-issues-policy-discussions/help-with-review-someone-please-respond-asap/69fded0559114e2ce755afa0 Title : Help With Review (SOMEONE PLEASE RESPOND ASAP)

1

0

Starwyvern77

24 Messages

•

362 Points

15 days ago

Hello, A few days ago, I submitted a review for the 1943 film, Edge Of Darkness, and it was rejected, saying that it didn't meet the eligibility criteria. Please, tell me what exactly it is that makes it ineligible. In addition, how is it possible to write a review about a movie relating to World War II without mentioning anything relating to the war, even if it's necessary to the film's story? #260508-133010-334621 Note: This comment was created from a merged conversation Link : https://community-imdb.sprinklr.com/conversations/i-need-to-know/help-with-a-review-again-please-respond-asap/6a00c3fefb85297d468cdb6a Title : Help With A Review - Again (PLEASE RESPOND ASAP)

4

0

F

Fran

Employee

•

4.1K Messages

•

42.1K Points

Hello Starwyvern77

The Review was rejected because there are many social comments. The review can be re written and re submitted based on the User Review guidelines.

Like

Reply

15 days ago

0

Starwyvern77

24 Messages

•

362 Points

@Fran

But said comments are relevant to the narrative of the story. How is it possible to write a review about something During World War II without even so much as a mention of the war?

Like

Reply

15 days ago

0

F

Fran

Employee

•

4.1K Messages

•

42.1K Points

The movie is about the War and we understand. Now the use of words such "propaganda" and social comments are also in the Review.

I encourage you to re write the review based on the guidelines and re submit.

Like

Reply

15 days ago

0

Starwyvern77

24 Messages

•

362 Points

@Fran

Okay, well, I removed all the mentions of the word "Propaganda" and such. Hopefully that will do it.

Thanks for the information.

Like

Reply

15 days ago

0

Starwyvern77

Please Respond - Help With A Review

Fran

Starwyvern77

Starwyvern77

Starwyvern77

Starwyvern77

Fran

Starwyvern77

Fran

Starwyvern77

Related Conversations

Helpful Widget