My contribution is gone

Hello, My contribution to the film One Battle After Another was approved on Oct. 10th (#251010-173346-117421) and visible for several days. It now seems to be gone. Thank you for your help in publishing it again.

Responses

Oldest First

Selected Oldest First

Ozzy

Employee

•

2.6K Messages

•

26.8K Points

2 months ago

Hi Julot, Thank you for your problem report. I have taken a look at your review, and can see that a particular section of it breaches our user review guidelines (linked below), as it can be interpreted as social commentary or "personal opinions on subject matter on which the film is based". The review is otherwise OK for approval, and as such we recommend either removing or editing your review to meet the guidelines stated. https://help.imdb.com/article/contribution/contribution-information/user-review-guidelines/GABTWSNLDNFLPRRH# Once you've submitted your edits, please copy your 18-digit submission reference into this thread, so we can monitor your review through processing, and ensure it is approved! I hope this helps!

5

0

J

Julot

3 Messages

•

90 Points

Hi Ozzy, Thank you for your quick reply. What I fail to understand is I have already edited the review, and it has been approved and published. Then it was removed without warning (no message, no email). I don't mind editing and re-editing. I'll gladly do it again. What part should be taken out now ? Thank you for your help. Julot

Like

Reply

2 months ago

0

Ozzy

Employee

•

2.6K Messages

•

26.8K Points

Hi Julot, No problem. Apologies, I could not see that your review had already been edited and re-published. However, I can inform you that it was since reported for removal by another contributor. Additionally, we do not support notifications for the removal of submitted content to IMDb. The third paragraph contains commentary that does not meet our user review guidelines in its current state, and therefore is the section that should either be removed or edited in accordance with the guidelines. To help you re-submit, the content of your previous review can be copied from your Contribution History (beta): https://contribute.imdb.com/contributions/history/. Thank you for your understanding!

Like

Reply

2 months ago

0

J

Julot

3 Messages

•

90 Points

Hi Ozzy, Thank you. I have re-edited and reposted the contribution following your advice. Apologies but I'm struggling to understand the following : my approved and published contribution was reported for removal by another contributor, but IMDB does not support notifications for the removal of submitted content. Is this contradictory or am I missing a point ? Thank you again for clarifying. Julot

Like

Reply

1 month ago

0

Maya

Employee

•

5.9K Messages

•

62.3K Points

@Julot- Hi, What Ozzy meant there is that yes, your approved review was later reported by another contributor for removal because it breached our guidelines. Therefore, the removal was approved. However, you were not notified of the removal because notifying contributors of a reported and/or removed submission is currently not a feature we support. Thanks!

Like

Reply

1 month ago

0

Marco

3.2K Messages

•

91K Points

@Maya: "However, you were not notified of the removal because notifying contributors of a reported and/or removed submission is currently not a feature we support." Is this on a roadmap? I think it would be good if this would be implemented.

Like

Reply

1 month ago

Julot

My contribution is gone

Ozzy

Julot

Ozzy

Julot

Maya

Marco

Related Conversations

Helpful Widget