15 Messages
•
470 Points
Merging Keywords
When I started this post I received this message.
"We found 2071 similar conversations Do any of these match what you're looking for?"
Oh, good. It's been answered already. NOPE! My idea is to include a "Merge Keywords" button or and option in edit page that will list all the keywords with check-boxes to select those words that should be merged and to chose the most appropriate keyword to keep, deleting all the others after being merged. It could even suggest other active similar keywords to be included in the merge but not linked to that title.
This was inspired when I checked out the keywords for Becoming Astrid (2018). Many of the keywords were redundant:
These could be merged into one keyword, maybe two.
older man attracted to younger woman
younger girl older man
older man younger girl relationship
older man young girl relationship
older man young woman relationship
older man young girl romance
older man young woman
older man younger girl
older man younger woman relationship
These may or may not be included in the above. Your ideas?
old young relationship
young girl seduces older man
I separated these because a sexual relationship could be separate from a non-sexual one, but these should be merged into a separate keyword from those above.
older man younger woman sex
older man younger girl sex
lder man has sex with young woman
older man young girl sex
older man teenage girl sex
I didn't look up similar keywords that were not used for this title. Maybe I should have, but I didn't know what to search for, that would give keywords not listed already.
"We found 2071 similar conversations Do any of these match what you're looking for?"
Oh, good. It's been answered already. NOPE! My idea is to include a "Merge Keywords" button or and option in edit page that will list all the keywords with check-boxes to select those words that should be merged and to chose the most appropriate keyword to keep, deleting all the others after being merged. It could even suggest other active similar keywords to be included in the merge but not linked to that title.
This was inspired when I checked out the keywords for Becoming Astrid (2018). Many of the keywords were redundant:
These could be merged into one keyword, maybe two.
older man attracted to younger woman
younger girl older man
older man younger girl relationship
older man young girl relationship
older man young woman relationship
older man young girl romance
older man young woman
older man younger girl
older man younger woman relationship
These may or may not be included in the above. Your ideas?
old young relationship
young girl seduces older man
I separated these because a sexual relationship could be separate from a non-sexual one, but these should be merged into a separate keyword from those above.
older man younger woman sex
older man younger girl sex
lder man has sex with young woman
older man young girl sex
older man teenage girl sex
I didn't look up similar keywords that were not used for this title. Maybe I should have, but I didn't know what to search for, that would give keywords not listed already.
nick_burfle
189 Messages
•
6K Points
6 years ago
2
Peter_pbn
Champion
•
14.4K Messages
•
329.9K Points
6 years ago
https://getsatisfaction.com/imdb/topi...
4
jeorj_euler
10.7K Messages
•
225.4K Points
6 years ago
2
keyword_expert
2.7K Messages
•
47K Points
3 years ago
I agree that many or most of these keywords could and should be consolidated. In fact, I believe all of them could probably be consolidated into this single keyword:
man-girl-relationship (44 titles)
Then, additional specificity could be added with these keywords:
man-teenage-girl-relationship (2 titles)
man-young-girl-relationship (not currently a keyword)
When a romance is involved, I would recommend this keyword:
man-girl-romance (not currently a keyword)
When sex is involved, in addition to the sex-related keywords that you pointed out, we also should not forget the "rape" keywords, because in most situations, sexual contact between a man and a girl is deemed statutory rape, even if the girl thinks she is "consenting":
man-rapes-a-girl (11 titles)
adult-man-rapes-a-teenage-girl (10 titles) (this one could just be "man" instead of "adult-man")
man-rapes-a-young-girl (not currently a keyword)
I wouldn't worry too much about people not being able to find the titles. If the keywords were consolidated, then the new keywords can be used to find the titles. Problem solved.
Finally, I should point out that I have used the term "young-girl" in several of these keywords. I think that is the best term for a girl who is younger than a teenager (i.e., 12 and younger). But I am apparently the minority in this thinking. Most contributors seem to prefer "little-girl" rather than "young-girl." To me, "little-girl" implies physically little, rather than young in age. But I do realize my opinion is in the minority on this point.
(edited)
0
0
bradley_kent
1.3K Messages
•
23.4K Points
3 years ago
As I've stated before, I use:
little girl/boy for someone 5 years of age or younger (not their physical size);
girl/boy for someone 6 to 12 years of age;
teenage girl/boy for someone 13-to-19-years of age;
woman/man for someone 20 to 59 years of age; and,
old woman/man for someone 60 years of age and over.
The use of the "young" adjective has always mystified me since it is so subjective (as is "old," of course. Same with "youth" and "adolescent," which I avoid.
It seems that "girl" and "boy" are often used for teenagers, and even for those in their 20s, 30s, etc., which seems like an unacknowledgement of reality.
(edited)
3
keyword_expert
2.7K Messages
•
47K Points
2 years ago
I included many of the keywords mentioned in this post in the following list of duplicate keywords, which were mass merged and set up for auto-conversion:
Duplicate Keywords - List #43 (Proposals for Permanent Merger and Auto-Conversion) ("-relationship" keywords)
Many of these keywords have been merged into "man-girl-relationship" and "older-man-younger-woman-relationship".
0
0