Masters of the Air review declined. Why?

Given the amount of inflammatory piffle that has gone through on this series, could someone explain why my review (#240218-172456-354804) has been knocked back? Can't see any obvious breach, unless "there are casualties in war" somehow counts a spoiler.

(There's even a review with the TITLED "Reply to jlftagchair", which is not supposed to happen is it?)

Responses

Oldest First

Selected Oldest First

Ozzy

Employee

•

2.6K Messages

•

27K Points

2 years ago

Hi @ShippersAreEvil,

Thank you for your problem report.

We have reviewed the content of your review and can confirm that it was declined because it features social commentary outside of the title's content itself. If you were to remove any commentary on other user opinions and reviews, and re-submit, your review should have no issue being approved.

We have also removed the review you've reported, as yes that is a breach of our user review guidelines.

I hope this helps!

4

0

ShippersAreEvil

36 Messages

•

596 Points

@Ozzy Sorry -0 still not clear what you are referring to -- I checked other reviews that have already been approved before drafting mine, and I can't see anything I have written that is different in approach. Perhaps you could be more specific (and then consistent)?

2 years ago

0

Bethanny

Employee

•

5.6K Messages

•

58.9K Points

@ShippersAreEvil Hi! More specifically, please keep in mind our guidelines mention no name calling, and you do name call people who criticize certain aspect of the title, resubmit without that comment and you should have no problem getting your review accepted.

Cheers!

2 years ago

0

ShippersAreEvil

36 Messages

•

596 Points

@Bethanny Sorry? How does it compare with the volume of disgusting misogynistic, homophobic and racist drivel that routinely gets through every time a character is regendered or made other than straight white?

At least try to work to one standard, rather than just providing an unchallenged platform for bigots.

2 years ago

0

Col_Needham

Employee

•

8.2K Messages

•

190.5K Points

@ShippersAreEvil Please see the user review guidelines at https://help.imdb.com/article/contribution/contribution-information/user-review-guidelines/GABTWSNLDNFLPRRH

If there are any live reviews which violate these guidelines then unfortunately they have slipped by our checking, sorry. You are welcome to report any such reviews via the “Report this” link under each review (as explained here).

Hope this helps.

2 years ago

ShippersAreEvil

Masters of the Air review declined. Why?

Ozzy

ShippersAreEvil

Bethanny

ShippersAreEvil

Col_Needham

Related Conversations

Helpful Widget