308 Messages
•
7.1K Points
It's Such a Beautiful Day to please help me solve this problem
I've tried to submit this correction many times but every time it gets rejected for some reason.
In 2012, Don Herztfeldt took his series of three short films about a character named Bill who suffers from a psychological breakdown (Everything Will Be OK (2006), I Am So Proud of You (2008), It's Such a Beautiful Day (2011)) and recut them into one feature length film (It's Such a Beautiful Day (2012)). For some reason, even though all of the credits for crew positions are there, the feature film version's IMDb page doesn't have any cast info. The cast info can easily be found by looking at the IMDb pages of the three short films it was cut from. (There's not much of a cast to speak of; just Don Hertzfeldt himself as the narrator and brief role for Sarah Cushman as the doctor in the third installment). Apparently, IMDb doesn't consider IMDb to be a reliable source, because every time I try to copy the same credits over to the feature version, my contribution gets rejected.
My latest attempt is here by the way: #240405-165547-772000
It's been a while since I've seen the film, but I don't think the feature version is split into segments; I recall it being told as one continuous narrative, which it is. I'm pretty sure my memory is correct, because I specifically remember how I couldn't find the third installment available anywhere in a form that was separate from the feature film version. When I chose to just watch the feature version instead of searching for it any longer, I remember not being able to tell exactly the third installment began. Anyway, to get to the point, I think in this case the cast credits shouldn't have "segment Everything Will Be Ok", etc, listed as attributes, since in the reedited version the individual "segments" are not separated.
Maybe there's something wrong with the way I've been trying to format the contribution and it just keeps getting automatically declined, but I give up trying to figure out what it is. I'm basically just copying the way it looks on the other titles.
VonPunk
785 Messages
•
15.2K Points
6 months ago
This is a standard IMDB rule when things are re-edited into a different format, they allow the shell listing but don't allow the credits to be added to it, only the original releases get the credits and they are connected to the film in the connections section.
13
timothy_gray_el34lojg1aih1
308 Messages
•
7.1K Points
6 months ago
This film should never have been deleted and that fact that it was is an utter travesty. I checked before, and the film had:
- 16K votes
- 35.2K people had it added to their watchlist.
- At least 999 user-created lists included it.
- 75 user reviews, 32 critic reviews.
- 2 awards nominations that were specific to this particular title
Now, I can't even edit any of my lists that had this title on it without getting an error message. Somebody with an ability to see reason, please take control of this situation. Restore this title if at all possible.
0
timothy_gray_el34lojg1aih1
308 Messages
•
7.1K Points
6 months ago
A title used by thousands of people on IMDb has been deleted for completely asinine reasons. Now, I can't edit any of my lists that happened to have included that title. When I click on "edit", I get this message:
The title in question is this: https://www.imdb.com/title/tt2396224/
This is what it looked like in 2022: https://web.archive.org/web/20231228073006/https://www.imdb.com/title/tt2396224/
The film has been on IMDb for over ten years. It as accumulated over 16k votes, 75 user reviews, it has been added to over 32k users' watchlists, and it has been included in at least 999 user-created lists. Presumably, every one of those list creators right now is having the same problem that I'm having.
All of this is apparently my fault for daring to complain about a slight, comparatively very insignificant data discrepancy. The one and only employee who engaged with this post decided to "solve" the problem by deleting the title. I feel like I brought my dog to the vet for a sore toe and the vet just took out a gun and shot it. This is worse than anything I could have possibly imagined would happen as a result of me creating that post. I'm sorry, everyone.
0
Witchillo
1 Message
•
62 Points
6 months ago
So, hi. I have NO idea where I am, or what happened here on this page this week but, I, as a person who is obsessed with the order of his logged movies in imdb realized that this one movie I watched last year is lost. I've been trying to figure out why for the last hour and I found this page. I don't know who this timothy guy or this bethanny girl think they are, but I know that you can't just delete a widely-known feature film because you think it is not one. I don't even know if it comes back to the database, my date of rating it will come back but I still demand it to comeback. Congratulations on being this toxic people. I hope you have such an ugly day.
1
sienel
Champion
•
189 Messages
•
12.7K Points
6 months ago
Just curious -
Does the combined "It's Such a Beautiful Day" differ meaningfully from things like the various Spike & Mike anthologies that are in the database (https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0102966/reference/) or the annual Oscar Shorts entries (https://www.imdb.com/title/tt2546294/reference/)?
It's been too long since I watched any of these to remember if any original material (e.g. new opening/closing credits or interstitials) was included.
2
0
gromit82
Champion
•
7.4K Messages
•
275.2K Points
6 months ago
@Bethanny: If the situation with the feature version of It's Such a Beautiful Day (2012) is as Timothy describes it, then I would agree with him that the 2012 film ought to be restored to the database as it was before this thread started. Deleting the film from the database altogether sounds like it was an incorrect decision. Note that the feature has received a significant number of reviews as a feature: see the Rotten Tomatoes page at https://www.rottentomatoes.com/m/its_such_a_beautiful_day/reviews.
How the credits for the feature should be listed is a separate issue; I don't have enough information to comment on that.
(edited)
1
matthew_scott_7622690
16 Messages
•
284 Points
6 months ago
Hi all,
It's Such a Beautiful Day (2012 - Don Hertzfeldt) has been deleted from the IMDb database.
Here is the tt number and link, these no longer work, but I have them in my own records
tt2396224
https://www.imdb.com/title/tt2396224/
This movie was in:
I think this error is the result of Hertzfeldt having made both a short and a feature film with the same name, so likely someone noticed there is a 2011 short and a 2012 feature with the same name, thought they were duplicate entries and decided to delete the 2012 entry.
Here is the link and tt for the short film:
tt2078648
https://www.imdb.com/title/tt2078648/
Essentially Hertzfeldt made three shorts of the same story and edited them altogether into a feature. This feature was released in cinemas, I personally went and saw the feature. This is the cinema I saw it in back in 2013, luckily the listing still exists: Cube: It's Such A Beautiful Day + The Don Hertzfeldt Experience (cubecinema.com)
This film is listed in the top 250 films from this century by the website They Shoot Pictures TSPDT - The 21st Century's 250 Most Acclaimed Films (by Ranking 250-1) (theyshootpictures.com) #186
Please can this title be restored.
Thanks for reading,
Matt
2
Col_Needham
Employee
•
7.2K Messages
•
178K Points
6 months ago
We have just restored the title and we will investigate what happened. Sorry for the inconvenience.
(edited)
7
timothy_gray_el34lojg1aih1
308 Messages
•
7.1K Points
6 months ago
I would like to formally apologize to everyone involved for my role in instigating and escalating this situation. In particular, I would like to apologize to @Bethanny, who did not deserve to be insulted and harangued just for disagreeing with me, and @VonPunk, who was only trying to help. I hope we can all put this behind us and get along better in the future. Also, a big thank you to @Col_Needham for resolving the situation. I hope everyone has a lovely rest of the weekend.
0