Cleaning to make after the merger of 2 IMDb pages

Hi Daniel,

Even if it has nothing to do with my initial request, here are some comments about what you said:

* I found information about the 2018 short film (https://www.imdb.com/title/tt7984616), so this one should be kept: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lost_Hearts

(look at « adaptations » section), https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nicholas_Amer

(look at « Filmography » section), http://www.severnfilmproductions.com/article02.html

* I do not find anything about the 2011 short (https://www.imdb.com/title/tt2020060). The director is unknown, as well as the production company. And the main actor (Nicholas Amer) has not this film in his filmography.

—> As a consequence, I will not ask for a merger, but for a deletion of the 2011 page. Otherwise, you will have wrong information in the target page (2 director names, an incorrect production company coming from the 2011 short, etc). Ask also for the deletion of the director and production company of the 2011 one. You could also create a post for all these actions and IMDb will do it safely for you. But a merger does not seem the proper solution to me in that case (only when the 2 pages are the same, with the same names, etc). Here, there is a good page and a wrong page.

Ok, you are better informed than me:-). So, the target page is the 2018 one. But you will have to remove the director’s name and I do not find any information about the 2011 production company (removal also?). Do the best anyway:-)

On Wikipedia page, it is the 2018 page only that is mentioned, so I do not agree with you: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lost_Hearts

(look at « adaptations ») and https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nicholas_Amer

(look at « filmography »). Maybe, something went out in 2011, but everyone talks about the 2018 version, so removing it from IMDb to keep a 2011 version is maybe not the right choice

Ask maybe IMDb team what they would do in that case. I think that usually it is the page of first release that has to be kept, but here people talk about the final version released in 2018. So, I do not know what to think

Anyway, good luck:-). It is not an easy item and I understand that you want to find the best solution.

Ok, I see. It’s a pity people go on Wikipedia to edit approximate things. Your dedication is a blessing, but few people seem to be like you. I noticed also bad behaviors of people on IMDb, not for the credits, but for the ratings & reviews: they create multiple accounts to change the rating and/or edit the same reviews (with slight changes) and then massively vote for these reviews with their fake accounts. These kind of behaviors sometimes demotivate me. If everyone could be as serious as you are, things will be different. Good luck and thanks for your dedication to help other people