2.7K Messages
•
47K Points
Are "filmed-in-" keywords allowed?
Someone (probably just one or two contributors) has been adding "filmed-in-" keywords to indicate the geographic places where titles were filmed. The contributor is particularly focused on titles filmed in Arizona.
I believe these "filmed-in-" keywords are not proper keywords. First, they may have nothing to do with the plot. Keywords are primarily supposed to be plot keywords, and sometimes a filming location is irrelevant to a title's plot.
Second and more importantly, IMDb already has other search functions to allow searching for titles filmed in specific geographic areas.
For example, here is a search for all titles filmed in Arizona (currently 7,795 titles):
https://www.imdb.com/search/title/?locations=arizona
Such locations searches can be combined with keyword searches. Here's a search for titles filmed in Arizona with the keyword "desert":
https://www.imdb.com/search/title/?locations=arizona&keywords=desert
Imagine if every title included keywords indicating every location where each title was filmed. That would be a lot of unnecessary (and duplicative) keywords.
If I'm correct that "filmed-in-" keywords are improper, can IMDb staff please delete and block these keywords?
filmed-in-phoenix-arizona (43 titles) | |
filmed-in-utah (41 titles) | |
filmed-in-canada (20 titles) | |
filmed-in-armenia (14 titles) | |
filmed-in-tempe-arizona (14 titles) |
filmed-in-los-angeles-california (4 titles) | |
filmed-in-scottsdale-arizona (2 titles) |
filmed-in-arizona (3 titles) | |
filmed-in-chicago (2 titles) | |
filmed-in-seattle (2 titles) | |
filmed-in-nova-scotia (2 titles) |
filmed-in-cleveland-ohio (2 titles) | |
filmed-in-las-vegas-nevada (2 titles) | |
filmed-in-new-york-city (2 titles) |
There are also some "filmed-in-" keywords with only 1 title; I could handle those myself rather than asking staff to delete them. But first, I will wait for confirmation that "filmed-in-" keywords are indeed improper.
Accepted Solution
Michelle
Employee
•
17.6K Messages
•
314.2K Points
3 years ago
Hi keyword_expert & gromit82-
Thanks for reporting and commenting. These are not eligible keywords as they unnecessarily duplicate Locations data on title pages, as already noted in your comments above.
I have now removed all live geographic "filmed-in" location keywords.
Cheers!
1
gromit82
Champion
•
7.5K Messages
•
276.5K Points
3 years ago
I agree with keyword-expert that these "filmed-in-..." keywords are just a duplication of the Location section and should not be accepted.
0