Champion
•
3K Messages
•
72.5K Points
Another keyword to merge and redirect
Since movies and television series can cover an entire lifetime of a character, having a character's title included is a little weird. James Gordon isn't always the police commissioner in various Batman and related movies and series. I suggest that we merge the following keywords:
commissioner-gordon-character ---> james-gordon-character
Gordon isn't always the police commissioner but he is always James Gordon.
keyword_expert
2.7K Messages
•
47K Points
3 years ago
I think I would oppose that merger/redirect.
There has been at least one other Commissioner Gordon character without the first name James.
Specifically, in this episode of Batman Beyond, James Gordon's daughter Barbara has retired as Batgirl and is serving as commissioner of the Gotham City police department:
https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0519399/reference/
Given that point, it makes most logical sense to me to keep these two keywords separate, even though both keywords will need to be used for many titles.
3
0
Michelle
Employee
•
17.5K Messages
•
313.3K Points
2 years ago
Hi @adrian & @keyword_expert -
My apologies for the delayed response on this keyword request, I'm following up on older threads to help resolve any outstanding issues.
I'm not personally familiar with these titles or characters, however, based on the comments within this thread it seems plausible that the keyword "commissioner-gordon-character" is relevant to keep if there are on-screen characters with this credited name.
Unfortunately, we do not have a good way to distinguish keywords where a character name is common, such as between "commissioner-gordon" in Title A and "commissioner-gordon" in Title B. However, as suggested above, in instances where a character is also known by a first name it would be useful to include that. For example, in Dexter Detective Morgan is also referenced as Debra Morgan, so an acceptable character keyword would be "detective-debra-morgan-character".
4
keyword_expert
2.7K Messages
•
47K Points
2 years ago
The final suggestion in this thread has now been implemented, and the thread can be marked as solved. Yay!
0