67 Messages
•
1.3K Points
#260905-024730-771000 - 2 items incorrectly declined
One Continuity Goof added and one Goof corrected to meet IMDb Guidelines; both declined without reason.
GOOF edit: 'Barbara Stanwyck slightly fluffs a line at 48:10+. "If there's anything come coming to you, I want half of it."' Miscellaneous --- Corrections were made i/a/w IMDb Goof guidelines regarding Timestamps and use of "Miscellaneous" as the Goof category:
- Per Section C - Categories, for "Miscellaneous", the Guide states, "This category is hardly ever used - if you can't shoehorn your goof into any of the above categories it's probably not a goof." An actor flubbing (I assumed "fluffs" was an acceptable term.) a line certainly isn't a "Miscellaneous" goof.
- Per Section D - Style Guide, item 9 Timestamps: 1st bullet - "Timestamping a goof where possible is encouraged, but the format must adhere to strict rules." [NOTE: *must adhere*]; 2nd bullet: "Please use the format (at around xx mins) or (at around xh xx mins)." [NOTE: this is what must be adhered to.]
GOOF Addition: 'When Barbara and Bradley are on the couch, there are several discontinuities on camera cuts. The most obvious one is after Barbara says "What's the difference?", and Bradley says, "Only this."'
"Reason Does not meet contribution guidelines. Your contribution has been declined. Please review our submission guidelines.
I'd suggest the reviewer take their own advice about reviewing submission guidelines. There are definite lapses of continuity in that section.






No Responses!